3 ms·
I've seen way too many screenshots of a dozen-line complete XHR wrappers being suggested[1] to complete a function to imagine Copilot as a generative machine. I
by rektide 5y ago
I've seen way too many screenshots of a dozen-line complete XHR wrappers being suggested[1] to complete a function to imagine Copilot as a generative machine. It's a somewhat fancy copy paste engine, with phenomenal search. But it's smuggled through enough complexity & machinery to obfuscate any legal obligations that might be attached to the original source material.
The article does not set itself up to address this at all:
> Since Copilot also uses the numerous GitHub repositories under copyleft licences such as the GPL as training material, some commentators accuse GitHub of copyright infringement, because Copilot itself is not released under a copyleft licence, but is to be offered as a paid service after a test phase.
I'm all for discussion of whether Copilot itself has to be copyleft. But to me, the immediate concern is that Copilot seems like a way to take copyleft works and remove the copyleft license from those works.
[1] https://mastodon.social/@cjd/106513694972486353 https://mastodon.social/@cjd/106513694972486353
- hnfong 5y agoIsn't that what GPL allows, and is what the AGPL is for if you don't want people to take your code and host it as an online service?
- rektide 5y agothe service itself is a source-code-copier. GPL does not permit you to copy source code without attribution. this copier does not provide attribution. as i just said, i'm not so interested in debating the source-code-copier's licensing. i think it could go either way but i don't really care. the copied source code that the source code copier copies is interesting to me, and feel like the stochiastic parrot act bullshit they are pulling is massive massive sinfully evil bullshit without attribution. the stochiastic parrot can't just ignore all the licensing of what it parrots out.