6 ms·
Sixty years of climate change warnings
- aliasEli 5y agoIt's a long well-written article, and its contents perfectly matches its title.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe essay is an exerpt of a book published in the coming week by the author, Alice Bell, titled Our Biggest Experiment. Given this sample, the book looks to be excellent. https://guardianbookshop.com/our-biggest-experiment-9781472974778.html https://guardianbookshop.com/our-biggest-experiment-97814729...
- firestarter223 5y ago"They still had hope back then. Reading that hope today hurts." - why? Nothing severe has happened yet. Article probably cherry picks the "best" predictions, too.
- Paianni 5y agoWhat would be severe to you?
- rob74 5y agoCities like Venice and countries like the Maldives having to be evacuated because of sea level rise? But it remains to be seen if we can stop that from happening with the agreements currently in place...
- firestarter223 5y agoRegions becoming uninhabitable, sea levels rising, mass extinctions. As of now it is difficult to find any significant damage that is not actually the result of direct human mismanagement that they try to blame on climate change. Edit: no, not climate change. Things like diverting water and pumping wells dry, planting the wrong trees and preventing small fires that leads to huge fires, for example.
- rob74 5y agoAre you including climate change in the results of direct human mismanagement?
- firestarter223 5y agoNo, I mean direct "mechanical" impact, agriculture, building, deforestation and so on.
- CarelessExpert 5y ago> Regions becoming uninhabitable, sea levels rising, mass extinctions. Every single one of those things has already started happening. Sea level rise is already starting to threaten low lying coastal areas, including places like Miami beach where sea water is more and more frequently seeping up through porous bedrock and flooding roads and other public spaces. It's also exacerbating the effects of king tides and creating far more destructive storm surges. Parts of India are more frequently hitting the wet bulb temperature where humans can no longer survive, something which will occur with increasing frequency. And we're smack in the middle of a major mass extinction event. What more do you want?
- firestarter223 5y ago"Started happening" - nothing severe has happened yet, though. And coastal regions often have other issues than rising sea levels. For example land sinking because too much water has been pumped from the wells. Also human settlements are probably expanding, at times into places that were not fit for building to begin with. The places with "wet bulb temperature" probably are uninhabited already. Such places have always existed (death valley perhaps an example in the US). I don't claim climate doesn't change, just the dramatic downsides don't seem to happen somehow.
- frereubu 5y ago> Nothing severe has happened yet. That sounds like the man who jumped off a tall building, and at each foor on the way down was heard to say "so far, so good..."
- firestarter223 5y agoWe can not continue listening to the alarmists. There is an infinite number of things that can go wrong. Yet here we still are.
- the_dune_13 5y ago> Yet here we still are. By we, you are talking middle to upper income countries not the poor countries in Africa and especially no the islands states in the Pacific. Or maybe you are not one of the relatives of the poor souls were lost in 50C heatwave in Canada last week. If those do not apply to you, sure we are here. Just add, at the moment.
- firestarter223 5y agoThose are also still here (with exception of the heat wave victims, which seem out of place in an affluent country. I would suspect failure of politics/health system. But heat waves have always happened).
- adrianN 5y agoWe have never listened to alarmists, or the world would be carbon neutral by now.
- drewcoo 5y agoOr the person selling umbrellas to the crowd below.
- itsoktocry 5y agoI hate to say it, but climate change is a classic tragedy of the commons problem. Countries are economically incentivized to "cheat". Until "we" are willing to, literally, go to war to enforce global emissions standards and other policies, it's hopeless.
- frereubu 5y agoQuite apart from the fact that wars tend not to go the way that the aggressors predict (Afghanistan comes to mind...) war is massively carbon intensive. I get your point about tragedy of the commons, but going to war about it is probably a good deal worse than doing nothing. I have so many questions too - who's going to go to war? What or who are they going to fight? It's such a strange idea.
- rich_sasha 5y agoSpeaking of the war: the Afghan conflict cost somewhere in the region of $1tn. Counterfactual, but I wonder how much that money would do for fighting climate change.
- wolverine876 5y agoPlenty of countries implement climate change protections, and do other things to protect the commons, especially the environment. It's a commonplace thing. It's really the US that is the exception on climate. There's some fetish about violence these days, despite living in a world where the international order and democracy, both non-violent solutions to politics, have built freedom and prosperity many orders of magnitude beyond anything in human history. We can do it. Let's stop talking about how hopeless we are and just get to work.
- Zababa 5y ago> It's really the US that is the exception on climate. I don't think it is. For exemple, Brazil and China are both terrible from a climate perspective. Africa is also not reducing their numbers of births. The USA may be behind Europe, but the rest of the world still exists.
- refurb 5y agoCan someone point me to a journal paper that proves an given event was due to climate change? Would be good to have.
- UncleMeat 5y agoEverything is statistical so you won't find absolute proof, but there are many such papers. Noah Diffenbaugh's group has a bunch related to droughts in CA.
- wolverine876 5y agoThe issue is politics and nothing else, and people rationally concerned about various public welfare issues, including climate change, seem afraid to fight. So to avoid a fight, they pretend that if they present a strong enough rational argument, the right will accept it. They've kept their heads in the sand for decades, and humanity has shown they can do that perpetually. The right is focused on politics above everything, and their singular tactic is aggressiveness at all times. They won't back down - why would they? Nobody has made them pay a price for it. To win, to do something about climate change, people will need to fight a political battle against a confident, aggressive, well-organized, well-resourced enemy. That is all that matters. The good news is that if you punch a bully in the mouth (politically), they quickly change their tune. And the good news is that their ideas are ridiculous and corrupting (to them). But so far, I haven't seen anyone willing to throw a punch (and if someone does, such as some progressives, the rest of the non-right turns on them; they don't want to provoke a fight!).
- mc32 5y agoIt is politics but it’s not right or left. I don’t see other political leanings doing much better? Maduro, the guy in Bolivia, Cuba, North Korea, Iran. What are they doing fundamentally differently than we are that is affecting climate change positively?
- wolverine876 5y agoI'm talking about political groupings in the U.S. The left clearly does much better on climate change. (That probably applies to other wealthy democratic countries, where Green parties are common.) I'm not sure how the countries mentioned are involved, or even what their political leanings are in this context. Iran is a highly conservative authoritarian theocracy, North Korea a totalitarian dictatorship that is nominally communist. What does that have to do with climate change?
- dredmorbius 5y agoA number of the references from the article can be found online. The 1974 CIA report "A Study of Climatological Research as It Pertains to Intelligence Problems" (33 pp., PDF) https://www.governmentattic.org/18docs/CIAclimateResearchIntellProbs_1974.pdf https://www.governmentattic.org/18docs/CIAclimateResearchInt... Background on "The Jasons": https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/06/jason-secretive-group-cold-war-science-advisers-fighting-survive-21st-century https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/06/jason-secretive-grou...
- walkedaway 5y agoThis article is disingenuous. 60 years ago, scientists were predicting global cooling, not global warming. Not to cover all avenues, its been changed to just "climate change." http://www.populartechnology.net/2013/02/the-1970s-global-cooling-alarmism.html http://www.populartechnology.net/2013/02/the-1970s-global-co...
- dwaltrip 5y agoThat’s actually a myth. Global cooling was a small minority of published papers in climatology at the time. They were many more papers discussing warming. Source: https://ams.confex.com/ams/pdfpapers/131047.pdf https://ams.confex.com/ams/pdfpapers/131047.pdf P.S. I learned this watching the excellent video by Veritasium on climate change misconceptions: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=OWXoRSIxyIU https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=OWXoRSIxyIU
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- loopz 5y agoNASA Study Goes to Earth's Core for Climate Insights (2011) https://www.nasa.gov/topics/earth/features/earth20110309.html https://www.nasa.gov/topics/earth/features/earth20110309.htm... "The researchers found that the uncorrected temperature data correlated strongly with data on movements of Earth's core and Earth's length of day until about 1930. They then began to diverge substantially: that is, global surface air temperatures continued to increase, but without corresponding changes in Earth's length of day or movements of Earth's core. This divergence corresponds with a well-documented, robust global warming trend that has been widely attributed to increased levels of human-produced greenhouse gases." Other links: https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/news/680/nasa-study-goes-to-earths-core-for-climate-insights/ https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/news/680/nasa-study-goes-to-ear... https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/nasa-study-goes-to-earths-core-for-climate-insights https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/nasa-study-goes-to-earths-core... https://www.co2levels.org/ https://www.co2levels.org/
- wolverine876 5y agoA 18 year old I know is visiting the west coast. I said: 'You picked the hottest summer in history for a visit!' They said: 'That's true. But it's also the coolest summer of the rest of my life.' Ouch. Look what inaction and politics has bequeathed to them. It's outrageous; it's sickening.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- CarelessExpert 5y agoI have to admit, I'm always a little nervous when I see this kind of techno-utopianism: > A star among these tools – sparkling alongside solar panels, heat pumps, policy systems and activist groups – is modern climate science. Obviously it's important not to simply give up and do nothing. There's plenty that can be done, now, to limit temperature rise below truly catastrophic levels. But it's also very easy to look at technology as a get out of jail free card, which is probably why you see so many carbon-intensive industries focusing on things like carbon capture: it let's us just layer new technology onto our existing, unsustainable practices. And then there's the whole topic of geoengineering... Science and technology give us a lot of tools, but ultimately it's our ability to wield those tools in a coherent fashion across the entire planet that will determine if we're successful at putting a lid on global warming. Unfortunately, after 60 years of inaction, I have little faith that humanity will pull it off... I suspect it's far more likely that, in 100 years or so, we'll look back on this time as the peak of human development while we look to a much diminished future as we try to cope with the world we've made for ourselves...
- kjsingh 5y agoWhile buying new property, I looked at the potential flood map w.r.t increase in sea levels. And now I think even that would not predict the true scale of destruction. sad but true.