4 ms·
This sort of thing is predictable. Twitter & co are leaving open a huge window for a competitor to come in and take a big chunk of users. The attempts are going
by roenxi 5y ago
This sort of thing is predictable. Twitter & co are leaving open a huge window for a competitor to come in and take a big chunk of users. The attempts are going to keep coming until one of them has solid technical foundations and sticks.
There were a lot of knee-jerk calls for some sort of government regulation or similar on the right when the censorship started to kick up a gear. Hopefully they'll learn that the first reaction is a mistake and that the market eventually corrects for that sort of power abuse.
- Nursie 5y agoBut if you don't control what's going on on your platforms they become a cesspit that most people don't want to go anywhere near. They either succumb to spam, or just allow the openly racist to dominate, as other participants tend to leave in disgust. These new platforms have generally all been a fantastic example of that, as have the older reddit forks/splinters (voat?)
- roenxi 5y agoThey'll figure it out eventually. There'll be a few failed attempts as people figure out that anything-goes doesn't work and eventually someone will find a good balance of moderation and freedom. There is little doubt that we'll see a lot of unimpressive attempts at a right wing social network. But since Twitter is politically hostile to an entire wing of politics, people will keep trying until a competitor hits the right notes. They don't have much to lose and a lot to gain by trying.
- Nursie 5y ago> Twitter is politically hostile to an entire wing of politics This is really quite a big claim, I'm not sure it's that cut and dried, personally. But then I don't tweet or care to read other people's tweets anyway. I think the whole thing is overblown and representative only of a few noisy minorities in the first place.
- Covzire 5y agoHere's a little experiment anyone can do to test this. Click any tweet from a prominent Republican politician. If the tweet is new, especially very new, the replies will be relatively supportive/agreeing with the politician. Within moments/minutes, anti-Republican messages will dominate the replies something like 95 to 1 and the first few replies will almost certainly be extremely rude, crude and emotionally vitriolic. The opposite happens to Democrat politicians, "thoughtful and sane" echoing replies are boosted to the top. Twitter gaslights conservatives and anti-gaslights the left. I saw this happen for the first time in real time when Trump first expressed his outrage when Twitter first amended his tweet that set off the whole S230 discussion. The first 5 minutes were nothing and I mean nothing but supportive tweets. After about 5 minutes, almost all the replies that were visible at the top were vitriolic and expressing anti-Trump views. Since then, I've been spotting this pattern everywhere, just not in real time. I think what probably happened is that the censors at twitter were scared of applying their gaslighting in light of Trump's threats, but that's just a guess. It's extremely obvious to me though that Twitter is purposely gaslighting conservatives by editorializing which anti-Republican replies get the most visibility.
- Nursie 5y agoThat's twitter users, not the platform itself. I don't see any "free speech" alternative being any different. In fact presumably such mobbing would be more prevalent and more vitriolic there, as there would be no standards of content or behaviour. What you're asking for there is a republican safe space that suppresses dissent, not free speech.
- leereeves 5y agoI would agree that the group of people who spend tons of time on social media tends to lean left, but it doesn't help that the platforms are actively driving away non-leftists. In other words, it's hardly surprising that the user base of Twitter leans left. (For example, when they suspended Jason Whitlock for tweeting "Black Lives Matter founder buys $1.4 million home in Topanga, which has a black population of 1.4%. She's with her people!".)
- pfisch 5y agoTucker Carlson can already barely hold advertisers and he has a massive platform on a pretty reputable network. Any social media site like this is going to be carlson++, so how will it ever stay afloat?
- viraptor 5y agoI think Twitter pretty much found the balance already since every extreme group from pretty much every angle is complaining about Twitter being biased against them. Meanwhile Twitter even tries to work around legal moderation requirements by splitting the visible parts of the network by country.
- zimpenfish 5y ago> or just allow the openly racist to dominate For some platforms, that's a feature, not a bug.
- rsynnott 5y agoThat's a very limited sort of platform, though, and certainly not anything for Twitter to be worried about (in fact, Twitter would _benefit_ from such a platform existing, as it might draw off some of the worst users). At that point you're looking at a platform that's not even attractive to the average racist; just to people whose _hobby_ is racism. So a small niche of extremely nasty people who other social networks don't particularly want to deal with anyway.
- willis936 5y agoIt's already happened. There is no hole to fill. 4chan adheres to the law, 8kun (formerly 8chan) does not. The users have already pushed free speech to its limit years ago.
- readflaggedcomm 5y agoIn what way doesn't it?
- willis936 5y agoChild pornography, threats, and conspiracy are not protected speech. In fact, it is illegal to host such content. 8kun does not moderate the content they host because they aim for maximum free speech.
- readflaggedcomm 5y agoThat's not what the disclaimer or the owners say, but it's taboo to see for yourself. Similar to that Byuu situation.
- willis936 5y agoQ: Into the Storm is worth watching. You get to hear what the siterunners have to say rather than what a banner they put up says.
- readflaggedcomm 5y agoNo banners in Watson's videos. What difference, at this point, does it make? The site is dead of activity, which shows how deranged this is. But questioning its state has to be buried and down-voted so it isn't seen.
- fredgrott 5y agoits a Free market of ideas! Why do we call it censorship when the byers reject buying an idea? Its not!
- diego_moita 5y ago> the market eventually corrects for that sort of power abuse. Oh, yeah, the typical libertarian daydreaming: "eventually markets will always fix themselves" . Because it worked so well for the last 30 years, right? We didn't get any oligopolies/monopolies in the tech industry, right? /s
- roenxi 5y agoWell ... yeah, it has worked pretty great? The last 30 years has been the best 30 years ever in terms of the minority view vs majority view power balance. Powered mainly by the hyper-liberal environment created by the internet. There has been a maybe 2 year rough spot and there is no reason to assume the market is not going to deliver.
- DarknessFalls 5y agoI'd be interested to know what views you consider to be "hyper-liberal".
- DarknessFalls 5y agoIt's not censorship when the rules are made clear. You are not permitted to make comments or videos that incite violence, such as the insurrection of the Capitol.
- TheAdamAndChe 5y agoYet the BLM riots and the politicians who praised them got a pass.
- shusaku 5y agoI don’t think it’s really a tech thing, I mean Twitter was a disaster tech wise for years. The fact of the matter is that there are armies of entrepreneurs out there all dreaming of making the next big social network, and failing. Even google couldn’t do it. It’s going to take more than a few big name right wing backers to get the ball rolling.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Twitter & co are leaving open a huge window for a competitor to come in and take a big chunk of users. There are some people that you may not want as your customers.