4 ms·
> It looks like Russia (and China) are vetoing any UN action. What are the alternatives? There are no alternatives, that is part of the problem. The UN was pri
by mschuster91 5y ago
> It looks like Russia (and China) are vetoing any UN action. What are the alternatives?
There are no alternatives, that is part of the problem. The UN was primarily created to prevent all-out war between the US and Russia... young people like me expect it to be more than that though.
In the past, as a result the US and various European nations have gone off on their own to engage in various conflicts, both in military actions and in economic sanctions, on sometimes extremely thin or nonexistent legal grounds.
That's unrealistic to expect here:
- there isn't much trade between Myanmar and the EU to sanction (and the bit that is can and will be covered by Russia and China)
- military action is out of the question since the US has more pressing problems to solve than a military junta - Taiwan and interior issues - and the EU is blocked by its 100% consensus requirements on foreign action, incompetent and underfunded armies and general instability
- generally, outside of human rights activists no one cares about human rights abuses, that is the sad and tragic reality.
- as for the UN: there isn't any hope for multilateral action any more there either, it's a dead paperweight. No single nation there acts on good faith and a sense of common humanity, everyone is just looking for their own interests.
- baybal2 5y ago> There are no alternatives, that is part of the problem. The UN was primarily created to prevent all-out war between the US and Russia... Please don't pervert the history. This wasn't the case. The UN was created as a reaction to the horror of WWII and the failure of the League of Nations. It was to become a League of Democracies, an iron fist against the next Nazi Germany wannabe, a guarantor of the "Never Again." It was the US who go the idea to get USSR into it, pretty much sabotaging it on the day 1. > There are no alternatives The alternative is here, and it's the resolution 377 action.
- zozbot234 5y agoThis is not a Nazi Germany wannabe, it's just a garden variety tinpot dictatorship. There are a lot like it in the world, and we've figured out that outside intervention is not a good idea in such cases. It's the responsibility of a country's own people to pursue free government for themselves, assuming that they care to. Reap what you sow, and all that.
- mschuster91 5y ago> It's the responsibility of a country's own people to pursue free government for themselves, assuming that they care to. Reap what you sow, and all that. This isn't possible often enough. There are countless dictatorships that use any means necessary to ensure their survival, from starving their populations (North Korea) to murdering or beating them up on the streets (Tiananmen massacre, Arab Spring revolutions) or silencing any opposition (Hongkong, Belarus). Most freedom movements need some form of support from the outside, be it arms, money, logistic or ideologic support.
- zozbot234 5y ago> There are countless dictatorships that use any means necessary to ensure their survival These things only matter in the short run but successful, enduring democratization is a very long game. Look at Taiwan and South Korea - relatively straightforward when looking at them from the outside, and yet they took decades to become stable democracies with real respect for fundamental rights. More challenging cases might take generations. > Most freedom movements need some form of support from the outside, be it arms, money, logistic or ideologic support. Most often, the needed support can come from the inside, as influential groups within the country start supporting a peaceful transition to liberal democracy. Arguably, this is even the best possible case.
- mschuster91 5y ago> as influential groups within the country start supporting a peaceful transition to liberal democracy For that, you need influential groups that can benefit from changing the status quo. In a country that has been suffering from decades of corruption, the elites are generally so widely despised by the population that they have to fear to be imprisoned at best and executed at worst, were they to lose power. It's even worse in countries like the Lebanon, Syria, Yemen or former Yugoslavian member states, where religion, ethnic disputes and sometimes hundreds of years worth of land disputes and squabbles come into the mix.
- 5y ago
- mschuster91 5y ago> It was to become a League of Democracies, an iron fist against the next Nazi Germany wannabe, a guarantor of the "Never Again." That is what both you and I hope that the UN would have been, but unfortunately not much based in reality. > It was the US who go the idea to get USSR into it, pretty much sabotaging it on the day 1. Without Soviet cooperation, the purpose of the UN would have been moot from day 1.