3 ms·
So GitHub Copilot has inherited all the bad practices of many StackOverFlow and GitHub side projects and generates them in front of you as 'assistance'. All th
by rvz 5y ago
So GitHub Copilot has inherited all the bad practices of many StackOverFlow and GitHub side projects and generates them in front of you as 'assistance'.
All the API keys are still working and who knows, someone might complain about a huge fee right in here because they forgot to revoke it. Only time will tell.
I am certainly going to avoid this contraption. No thanks and most certainly no deal.
Downvoters: So are you saying GitHub Copilot DOES NOT do the following:
Leak working API keys in the editor.
Generate broken code AND give you the wrong implementation if you add a single typo?
Copy and regurgitates copyrighted code verbatim.
Guesses 1 out of 10 tries.
Send parts of your code when you type in the editor.
Are you VERY sure?
- dolmen 5y ago> Leak working API keys in the editor. The content of your editor is sent by Copilot to its cloud service (the FAQ says: "The GitHub Copilot editor extension sends your comments and code to the GitHub Copilot service"). So yes any editor content is leaked, including sensitive information. But is this content sent to other Copilot users? AFAIK, no. The FAQ mentions the OpenAI Codex as the training set. https://openai.com/ https://openai.com/
- dolmen 5y agoI just had a look at the OpenAI website. They advertise an English-to-French translation service powered by AI. But it appears that nobody who is French native has even reviewed the service presentation. When the marketing material is just a joke, what can you expect in production if as a customer you use the service? Just this example tells me much about the internal organization of the company.