4 ms·
I was never into surround, but having a proper 2.1 setup has always been a huge priority. I've been rocking a pair of Polk RTI12s and a hand built subwoofer for
by bob1029 5y ago
I was never into surround, but having a proper 2.1 setup has always been a huge priority. I've been rocking a pair of Polk RTI12s and a hand built subwoofer for the last decade and I can't imagine upgrading.
Even the highest end soundbar on the market today would be a drop in the bucket compared to what this setup is capable of. I actually have a few sound bars/docks/etc on hand to compare. It is comedy at best.
- globular-toast 5y agoPeople are often surprised at how encompassing a sufficiently wide stereo setup is. My stereo speakers can go down to 50Hz so I don't consider a subwoofer to be essential. However, with a larger screen and multiple people viewing, a centre speaker is a good improvement. The ghost centre channel on stereo only really works if you're sitting in the sweet spot.
- 2rsf 5y agoBut that is not what soundbars are about, they are meant to look nice first and only then sound good
- willis936 5y agoThere's no replacement for displacement. Most people see the subwoofer price tags and skip them. I got a 12" Dayton sub for $150. Worth every penny. I wish there were more closed enclosure subwoofers for lower group delay. Building seems like an intriguing route. There's a lot of theory that goes into design, so I'd have to find some time and passion for it. The passion is easy. Time, not so much.
- bluescrn 5y ago> Most people see the subwoofer price tags and skip them. Or they are aiming for good quality sound (in particular, clear dialogue) at relatively low volumes. In which case, adding a center speaker will be more beneficial than adding a sub. (Some of us have neighbours who really wouldn't appreciate us attempting to recreate a cinema-volume experience at home...)
- willis936 5y agoSubs don't need to be cranked up. You could simply enjoy hearing sub 100 Hz sounds at a reasonable volume. A center channel isn't needed to increase clarity. Buying a center channel speaker without first knowing your stereo speakers' radiation pattern and positioning them and your seating appropriately is a waste of money.
- bob1029 5y agoThe magical point of crossover is more like ~50Hz in my experience. If you can get mains that go as low as 50hz and you set crossovers properly, the chances that the subwoofer is going to screw up clarity/stereo imaging is really small. At that point it is more about making sure the kettle drums provide authentic presence (i.e. small cracks in your drywall).
- grandinj 5y agoI built a sealed box around a Sony 15 inch car speaker. Does a really nice job and didn’t need any theory because sealed boxes are inherently more tolerant.it’s a cube about 2 and something foot on a side. Knocked it together with nails and a jigsaw. Yeah I’m a really hack wood worker :)
- bob1029 5y agoYou can actually get kits that are pretty hard to screw up these days: https://www.parts-express.com/Dayton-Audio-18-Reference-Series-HO-Subwoofer-and-Cabinet-P-300-7094 https://www.parts-express.com/Dayton-Audio-18-Reference-Seri... You'd be hard pressed to find something as good as that DIY kit for <$2000 in the retail marketplace.