4 ms·
Well, if I gave my kid five bucks and sent them to the store to buy a gallon milk, there wouldn't be any 'credit' or 'exposure' or 'risk' or 'volatility' involv
by michaelt 5y ago
Well, if I gave my kid five bucks and sent them to the store to buy a gallon milk, there wouldn't be any 'credit' or 'exposure' or 'risk' or 'volatility' involved.
Are we to believe these cutting edge financial institutions with their sub-millisecond high frequency trading, specialists in order execution, eight-figure salaries and dedicated high-speed microwave links are somehow unable trade cash for goods like every store does hundreds of times a day?
- TeMPOraL 5y agoNot to defend Robinhood, but the GME debacle was not like you sending your kid for milk; it was like everyone panicking and sending their kids to the same store, to buy a whole cart of milk each. As the early months of 2020 demonstrated, brick&mortar stores don't handle deviations from regular buying pattern well either, and having cash in hand doesn't change anything.
- real-dino 5y agoThat's not how brokers should work though, speaking in code, they are a wrapper around the market to make an interface that regular people can use. Price discovery means that buy/ask spread changes based on supply and demand, were this the case, and there was no collusion, then there would have been no need to shut down trading. The problem is the supply was inflated due to naked shorts, and Robin Hood's clearing house/business partner (Citadel) was caught with their pants down facilitating this naked shorting. Under normal market mechanics, there would be no panic. The price would have increased, early adopters would have gotten profit, late adopters would have missed out and lost as the correct price was found. The January blocking of trades was a desperate 'Hail Mary' to prevent an actual squeeze, and it *worked*. Calculations based on married put/calls shows that 190% of GME has, and still is shorted. There is no way to close the short position without increasing demand. https://www.reddit.com/r/Superstonk/comments/oc4f79/well_there_it_is_more_mathevidence_pointing_to/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Superstonk/comments/oc4f79/well_the... Yes, this is conjecture, but the author is well respected, and if you can disprove any of it, reddit is very happy to help you strengthen/disprove it's case. It's all seems quite cultish over in superstonk, but no-one believed Michael Burry back in 2008.
- paulgb 5y ago> The problem is the supply was inflated due to naked shorts, and Robin Hood's clearing house/business partner (Citadel) was caught with their pants down facilitating this naked shorting. What is the “caught with their pants down” referring to? I’ve seen dubious speculation but this is the first I’ve heard of them being caught on anything.
- real-dino 5y agoThey had a naked short position, one that could not be covered, and when the price rose too high, they would be margin called. When all the shares on the market are synthetic (fake), and retail and investors own more shares than are issued, then there is a serious problem that can either be brushed under the rug, or untangled by force (liquidation) Citadel itself is a hedge fund AND a market maker, it has two arms both ran by Ken Griffin. The path they were going down pre January was to short Gamestop into bankruptcy with no means to raise capital, much like Toys R us was. When Gamestop got a new CEO, and changed direction, they had already gone 'all-in' with their shorting with no way out. Main thing about shorting, it's an infinite risk position, but hedgefunds have historically been able to short into oblivion.
- paulgb 5y agoThat’s aligned with what I’ve heard speculated, but what’s the part where they were caught? The reddit post doesn’t point to a Citadel link, unless I’m missing something.
- real-dino 5y agoNot literally caught, they are stuck in a position of covering and liquidating or seeing how far they can kick the can down the road.
- gruez 5y ago>Price discovery means that buy/ask spread changes based on supply and demand, were this the case, and there was no collusion, then there would have been no need to shut down trading. 1. they didn't shut down trading, only forced positions to go into close-only 2. they absolutely needed to do that, given that they were at risk of not being able to meet deposit requirements, which would mean they would have to suspend trading for all stocks >Calculations based on married put/calls shows that 190% of GME has, and still is shorted. There is no way to close the short position without increasing demand. 1. shorts in excess of 100% doesn't indicate anything nefarious, due to synthetic longs created by shorts 2. I'm very skeptical of these "calculations", when official numbers put short interest at far lower than that, eg https://fintel.io/ss/us/gme https://fintel.io/ss/us/gme. >Yes, this is conjecture, but the author is well respected, Is he? Respected by whom? The superstonk community? The financial community? If it's just the latter it doesn't mean much. >It's all seems quite cultish over in superstonk, but no-one believed Michael Burry back in 2008. “But the fact that some geniuses were laughed at does not imply that all who are laughed at are geniuses. They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.” -- Carl Sagan