4 ms·
I have a question: > we picked a few stocks, and sold them to each other for a very low price, and then bought all of them up as the other students watched the
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
I have a question:
> we picked a few stocks, and sold them to each other for a very low price, and then bought all of them up as the other students watched the trends. We repeated this for 1/2 of the stocks in the simulation.
I can see how you could use this strategy to exchange a fairly low amount of money for these stocks. But that would mean you have less money than you started with, and more stock.
> We then sold each other 1 share of those stocks for $99.99 (the maximum price in the simulation), and ended up with almost all the money.
And then this trade causes you to have the same amount of money and the same amount of stock. How did you get the money back? Did you actually end up with almost all of the money, or did you end up with almost all of the market capitalization?
It shouldn't be possible to make any sales of a stock at the maximum price, because the only thing that can happen to you, if you buy a stock at the maximum price, is that the price of your stock goes down.
- mikewarot 5y agoThe goal of the class was maximum stock portfolio value (as set by market valuation). Everyone in the class started with a random set of stocks, and a set amount of funds. We looked at our portfolios and decided which to pump, and which to dump... then reversed when it was time to max out our portfolio values. When everyone is focused on the small picture, it is really easy to play the macro game. Note: You could put any price on a sell order, but someone had to match it in order to buy, so two people could quickly set the price of anything with a 1 share transaction. It's been almost 40 years, but I think we maxed out things with few hours work across a semester.
- ganafagol 5y agoYou didn't answer the question though. Sounds like the answer is "yes, we maxed the total market cap" which is distinctly different from "we ended up with almost all the money". You didn't have the money, you only had a fake stock valuation bubble.
- mikewarot 5y agoThat's a very good point! Had the Prof been a better teacher, he might have pointed it out, instead of me learning that lesson on HN decades later. 8) I never worried about the funds, only the portfolio value, since the funds were a zero sum game.
- mola 5y agoYou go to the bank leverage your amazing portfolio, now you have real money. And when everything comes crushing down, you're too big to fall, so the govt/banks bail you out. Amazing system we got.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoI'm talking about the game. In reality, stocks don't have a maximum value. But it also sounds like it's worth noting here that in reality, you cannot borrow money based on a stock valuation set by a very low-volume trade to which you were a party.
- kebman 5y agoUnless you're the bank yourself. But they don't do stuff like, that, right? Right?