2 ms·
> Sideloading is a threat to privacy because it allows apps to ignore the consent requirements the App Store enforces. As it stands, if any app wants access to
by heavyset_go 5y ago
> Sideloading is a threat to privacy because it allows apps to ignore the consent requirements the App Store enforces. As it stands, if any app wants access to your contacts, your camera, your microphone, your photos, etc, it must ask first. Allowing sideloading removes this protection, and apps installed that way could simply siphon all your data silently.
There's no reason that the OS can't implement sandboxes and enforce protections for such data. There's literally decades of research on operating system security.
Besides, when we forgo system safety in favor of corporate gatekeeping, that isn't security. In fact, such a scheme is responsible for mass distribution of malware. Apple's App Store is responsible for distributing over half a billion copies of Xcodeghost to iPhone and iPad users[1], and that's just one piece of malware.
[1] https://www.vice.com/en/article/n7bbmz/the-fortnite-trial-is-exposing-details-about-the-biggest-iphone-hack-of-all-time https://www.vice.com/en/article/n7bbmz/the-fortnite-trial-is...
- nodamage 5y agoPeople always cite sandboxing as some kind of panacea but the problem is sandboxing is entirely incapable of preventing bad actors from abusing permissions that were originally granted for legitimate purposes. For example: I might be okay with granting a messaging app access to my contacts to make it easier for me to send messages to people, but that doesn't mean I'm okay with that app exfiltrating my contacts to build a shadow graph of my social network to sell to advertisers. Putting a permissions dialog in front of my contacts only solves the problem of whether an app is allowed to access my contacts in the first place, there are zero restrictions on what can be done with that data once access is granted.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> For example: I might be okay with granting a messaging app access to my contacts to make it easier for me to send messages to people, but that doesn't mean I'm okay with that app exfiltrating my contacts to build a shadow graph of my social network to sell to advertisers. > Putting a permissions dialog in front of my contacts only solves the problem of whether an app is allowed to access my contacts in the first place, there are zero restrictions on what can be done with that data once access is granted. There's no reason that sandboxes have to be so lenient that this is possible. Permissions can be fine grained, and network connections can be filtered, restricted and denied. Contact access doesn't have to be black or white, either. On systems that work for the user, you can even feed dummy data to apps if you want to.
- nodamage 5y agoI'm sorry but I don't see how any of that actually solves the underlying problem of granting a third-party access to data you don't want to see abused.