2 ms·
Well, what's "smart?" Native of Australia were not considered smart 200 years ago; but now we appreciate their lifestyle and culture a whole lot more. Which att
by h2odragon 5y ago
Well, what's "smart?" Native of Australia were not considered smart 200 years ago; but now we appreciate their lifestyle and culture a whole lot more. Which attitude is "smarter?" What will we think about it in another 100 years?
Merely bringing everyone along doesn't ensure "smart"; look at Japan in ww2. They had an admirable unity of purpose, or at least a lack of vocal internal disagreement... Did that improve the characters of their actions?
I disagree that any individual human has much need to consider "humanity as a whole" in their decision making; i don't think we are smart enough, or can see enough, to hope to think logically about such scales. The best we can do is be the best we can be in our scope, and let the things out of our scope happen as they will.
- username90 5y ago> Native of Australia were not considered smart 200 years ago; but now we appreciate their lifestyle and culture a whole lot more. Do we? I don't see it. Their lifestyle isn't sustainable with modern population levels, billions would die. Of course killing off billions of people would fix climate change problems, but people wouldn't say that is a good solution.
- h2odragon 5y agoPerhaps: "Their culture was more appropriate to their circumstances than was initially appreciated." I agree, killing billions to fix climate change would be distasteful.
- fuzzfactor 5y ago>Their lifestyle isn't sustainable with modern population levels Exactly. Their culture not only looks more sustainable, it proved itself sustainable over thousands of years without leading to the devastating growth & overpopulation of the 21st century, which is the primary reason that for so many (aboriginal & global) it will not end well.