3 ms·
Are “cosmic rays” actually the only or primary way bits get flipped? Or is it just a stand-in for “all the ways non-ECC RAM can spontaneously have an erroneous
by Waterluvian 5y ago
Are “cosmic rays” actually the only or primary way bits get flipped? Or is it just a stand-in for “all the ways non-ECC RAM can spontaneously have an erroneous bit or two”?
- heyoni 5y agoThe latter apparently.
- bloak 5y agoAccording to Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft_error https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft_error): "in modern devices, cosmic rays may be the predominant cause". However, radioactive isotopes in the packaging used to be a major cause. I liked this bit: "Controlling alpha particle emission rates for critical packaging materials to less than a level of 0.001 counts per hour per cm2 (cph/cm2) is required for reliable performance of most circuits. For comparison, the count rate of a typical shoe's sole is between 0.1 and 10 cph/cm2."
- vbezhenar 5y agoFaulty RAM can produce errors and it's hard to catch those, even memtest might not detect it. I'm not sure if non-faulty non-ECC RAM can spontaneously have errors, but you can't be sure, cosmic rays are real, unless you've put your PC into a thick lead case, LoL.
- toast0 5y agoIn my experience with ECC RAM on couple thousand servers over a few years, we had a couple machines throw one ECC correctable error and never have an issue again. It seemed more common for a system to move from no errors to a consistent rate; some moved to one error per day, some 10/day, some to thousands per second which kills performance because of machine check exception handling. The one off errors could be cosmic rays or faulty ram or voltage droop or who knows what, the repeatable errors are probably faulty ram, replacing the ram resolved the problem.
- tgv 5y agoWell, "row hammer" notoriously can do that too.