4 ms·
That's not what actually happened here (probably), but think of relatively heavy atoms like iron, ejected from a supernova at close to the speed of light. They'
by noduerme 5y ago
That's not what actually happened here (probably), but think of relatively heavy atoms like iron, ejected from a supernova at close to the speed of light. They're not really "rays". They're solid particles that punch holes in everything. The good news is, mostly they're ionized and they get repelled away from hitting the planet's surface by our magnetic field (generated by the big hot iron magnet that's churning under our crust). But in the rest of space where there's no field like that, getting lots of tiny puncture wounds from high-velocity iron particles is pretty normal. It does a lot of damage to cells and DNA in a cumulative way pretty quickly.
To answer your question, shielding is possible but it is much harder in space than it is under the magnetosphere. Even so, a stray particle can wreak havoc. Shielding for the purposes of data protection on earth is essentially a risk/reward analysis. Anyone could get hit by a cosmic bullet, but the chances are pretty low. The odds of an SSD flipping bits on its own are significantly higher.
- Leparamour 5y ago> That's not what actually happened here (probably), but think of relatively heavy atoms like iron, ejected from a supernova at close to the speed of light. They're not really "rays". Wow, I have to admit I always assumed cosmic rays to be gamma radiation but alpha particle radiation sounds a lot more scary. Does anyone happen to know if computers engineered for the space station or shuttles have already some built-in (memory)redundancy or magnetic shielding to account for damage by cosmic rays? I imagine a system crash of the life support systems in space would be devastating.
- ben_w 5y agoRadiation hardening is basically everything you can manage with the weight limit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_hardening https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_hardening IIRC nobody is currently using magnetic fields for shielding, I don’t know if that’s due to insufficient effectiveness, power consumption, or unwanted interactions e.g. with Earth’s magnetosphere.
- myself248 5y agoI've always wondered about that. Seems to me that if you can shield one side from the sun's heat and expose the other side to the cold of space, an MRI magnet's superconductors should be quite happy with the temperature. A big ol' magnet would be a pain to charge up once, and then provide long-term shielding.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- verall 5y agoMRIs are big electromagnets and they use big power and produce big heat. In space you have no convection so you must radiate away all of your heat which is challenging. Maybe you can make something better with superconductors that doesn't use much power, but I don't think it exists yet.
- ben_w 5y agoSuperconductors famously don’t produce heat. Putting a superconducting magnet in shade (though that includes from the Earth not just from Sol) will keep it cool once it gets cool. This is what the James Webb is going to be doing, though for non-superconducting reasons.
- myself248 5y agoUm, what? The magnet in an MRI is a superconducting electromagnet. It needs power once, to charge it up, then you close the loop and it just sits there being a superconducting electromagnet. The only power used continuously is for cooling, which is to say, when ambient room heat leaks in, it has to be carried out again. The magnet itself does not produce heat; it has no electrical resistance because it is a superconductor.
- adrian_b 5y agoThe vast majority of the cosmic radiation consists of protons, i.e. hydrogen ions. Light ions, e.g. of helium, lithium or boron are also relatively abundant and heavier ions are less abundant. There are also electrons, but in smaller quantities, because they can be captured by ions. The high speed protons collide with the atoms of the Earth atmosphere and the collisions generate a huge variety of particles, but most of them have a very short lifetime, so they decay before reaching ground level. At ground level, the cosmic radiation consists mostly of muons, because they have a longer lifetime, so they survive the travel from the upper atmosphere where they are generated, until ground level. Only extremely few of the particles from the primary cosmic radiation, i.e. protons, reach ground, because most are deflected by the magnetic field of the Earth and the remaining protons lose their energy in the collisions with atmosphere, by generating particles, which eventually decay into muons.
- joshspankit 5y agoI had thought that Starlink would become extremely compelling when the servers were in orbit as well, but maybe that’s naive. Cubesats with massive arrays of active storage might be far too difficult (aka costly) to protect properly.
- MayeulC 5y agoOne of the issues with putting servers in orbit is cooling; you can't just use fans in space. On the other hand, real estate is pretty cheap. Servicing is hard, though, and micrometeorites are another risk. Plus launch costs being high, and radiation an issue, I don't see it happening any time soon outside of very specific areas.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoForget cooling for a minute. Cooling dissipates energy but you need to collect the energy first and worry about powering the server. It’s going to be a solar-plus-battery system, which is heavy and expensive, with substantial launch costs.
- MayeulC 5y agoNot sure you need a big battery when you have almost 24/7 sunlight, depending on the altitude. Of course, latency is another issue.
- willis936 5y agoRadiation cooling is pretty dramatic in space. With an isolated radiation shield/mirror from the sun and a decent sized heatsink, you can have a lot of cooling power on hand. A server isn't going to be pumping out nearly as much heat as a rocket engine, and launch vehicles don't tend to overheat.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoYou can’t just put an SSD or whatever in orbit and expect reasonable read latencies at all times. It’s in orbit. It moves. Half the time it’s on the wrong side of the planet.