4 ms·
Is there a law? Or are the platforms in question voluntarily using guidelines as guidance? Are platforms punished in the courts for failing to follow guidelin
by klyrs 5y ago
Is there a law? Or are the platforms in question voluntarily using guidelines as guidance? Are platforms punished in the courts for failing to follow guidelines or implement moderation? As far as I know, the answers to the above are a resounding "no," and it follows that this isn't state censorship. It's the freedom of association, and freedom of speech, exercised by corporation-persons.
- falcolas 5y agoCorporation-persons. Is there a more dystopian concept in existence? Corporations are NOT PEOPLE. They're made up of people, but the entity itself is NOT A PERSON.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- klyrs 5y agoWhile I agree with you, that's how the supreme court has interpreted the constitution. Let's take the strawman out of the picture and accept the fiction that corporations are not people. But, they are still not the state. They do not replace government services in any meaningful way -- choice of what to publish, and what not to publish, is firmly the role of private persons and commerce. Maintaining social media sites is not the role of government. Ergo, this is not state censorship.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't repeat ideological boilerplate on HN and please don't use allcaps for empahsis - this is also in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- chroem- 5y agoIs it boilerplate? It seems very relevant to the discussion, given that it's addressing a specific point in the parent comment.
- dang 5y agoBoilerplate has to do with how often something gets repeated, so it's boilerplate independent of where it's inserted; which is kind of the problem with it.
- roywiggins 5y agoCorporate personhood is older than America. Without legal personhood, how do corporations own anything? They've always been treated like legal persons, because that's sort of what corporations are for. They're legal entities that can own stuff and do some things, like hiring people and buying and selling. That doesn't work without them in some sense being treated like persons in the eyes of the law. What they're not are natural persons. Exactly how many legal rights corporations should have is a very good question, of course. But people get bent out of shape about corporate personhood as if it's new or particularly Orwellian. (Governments have always been legal persons- you can sue the government in court- if it lets you- and the government can sue you. The government owns property, pays salaries, and so on.)
- leereeves 5y agoThe article suggests that government employees may be consulting with YouTube in these censorship decisions. And that consultation would seem to be prohibited by the first amendment, just as police aren't allowed to consult with PIs to violate people's rights, even if the PIs volunteer to do so. (In other words, it's the gov employees, not YouTube, who would be violating people's rights by doing this.)
- klyrs 5y agoIs YouTube doing that voluntarily, or is that consultation required by law?
- salawat 5y agoIt doesn't really matter given the quid pro quo that could be facilitated through such engagement. There are more ways of implementing incentive structures and control mechanisms than you can possibly imagine, which is exactly why people are right to be concerned.
- akomtu 5y agoIt's the 3rd option: YT follows off-the-record recommendations to avoid potential problems with authorities. There are written, but unofficial, per-country rules and there's a well defined process to squash dissent: ML models analyze videos and comments to find non-complaint users, numerous contractors look at the automated flags and write their summaries, corp employees, up to VP level, review the reports and cancel the non-complaint users.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chroem- 5y agoCorporations don't have freedom of speech and it is misleading to suggest that they do. In fact, there is an enormous amount of legal precedent for mandated corporate speech. If you don't believe me, look at your nearest "nutrition facts" label.
- klyrs 5y agoThat precedent is, in fact, quite pertinent. Contrast with various platforms' labeling of misinformation, a law mandating such labeling would be wholly consistent. But we don't even have that. First, the government would need to establish that the people are harmed by the lack of labeling.
- srtjstjsj 5y agoNutrition Facts rules apply the same to humans and corporations.
- II2II 5y agoIf I'm interpreting what the author said correctly, it is an incredibly resounding no. It sounds like these platforms are using the CDC as a credible source for information and the platforms are creating their own guidelines for what can and cannot be said. Being concerned about treating the government as a reliable source of information is one thing, but conflating it with guidance on acceptable speech is quite another.