3 ms·
The premise that humans are smarter is appealing. The rationalization is big brains. But my iPhone fits in my pocket and is more capable than a room filling EN
by brudgers 5y ago
The premise that humans are smarter is appealing. The rationalization is big brains.
But my iPhone fits in my pocket and is more capable than a room filling ENIAC. SQL's "ORDER BY" is more efficient than writing sorting code myself.
Everywhere we look at computation, less is more sophisticated than more.
"Humans are the smartest" makes us feel good. That is a reason to question its accuracy.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoI don't understand you. Humans are objectively the smartest animals, and the iPhone and SQL are proof of that.
- brudgers 5y agoIf computation exists independent of humans, then the iPhone and SQL are evidence that small is more sophisticated. If computation is not independent of humans, then there is no basis for a claim to objectivity. SQL and iPhones are simply all we know because we are limited to human experience. Experience which we know is at times fallible…we might be phlogiston wrong again. What perhaps doesn’t register is at best it makes no difference if humans are smartest. It doesn’t make us smarter. At worst, belief that we are smartest makes us dumber.
- DougWebb 5y agoYour iPhone is far more complex than an ENIAC; the only difference is that its transistors are much smaller. To make an iPhone using ENIAC-sized transistors you'd probably fill a building, or city block, or even more. Neurons, on the other hand, are pretty much the same size in all animals. So brain size, neuron count, and neuron interconnectivity, all correlate with mental complexity.
- brudgers 5y agoCircuit boards are pretty much the same thickness for devices of vastly different computational capability. Similarly chips of similar dimensions can vary greatly in power. But more tellingly, circuit boards with fewer chips are often more sophisticated than bigger boards with more chips. There is no guarantee that number of neurons is a meaningful way of estimating computational power…a ziplock full of neurons doesn’t show much intelligence.