5 ms·
Google is not the cause of the housing crisis. It’s purely demographic. Count up all the people that graduated high school in your town and subtract the number
by jeffbee 5y ago
Google is not the cause of the housing crisis. It’s purely demographic. Count up all the people that graduated high school in your town and subtract the number of people who died, and that’s how many houses you need to build that year. Simple demographics and this figure has been ignored in most Bay Area cities for fifty years.
- xienze 5y agoEhh I think it’s a little more complicated than that, and I’ve argued this for years, that Google et al certainly plays a part. Consider their infamous busses, that allow employees who simply can’t fathom the idea of living in Mountain View to easily live in SF and commute. Without those I think employees wouldn’t be shielded from the consequences of the whole “live in the city, commute into the suburbs” thing.
- jeffbee 5y agoWhat is "infamous" about a bus? It's a workaround for the Bay Area's awful/nonexistent transportation system. Why aren't you carping about VMWare's "infamous cars" or the millions of cars driven every day to other companies without buses? Anyway the buses only explain partially how Googlers and other tech employees can survive the housing crisis, not what caused it. The cause is extremely simple. Births - Deaths = Growth. Don't overthink it.
- seoaeu 5y ago> What is "infamous" about a bus? They're considered a symbol of the class divide. Not a cause, but just a visible display of the income inequality present in the city. Poor people don't get a "workaround" for the the Bay Area's awful/nonexistent transportation system, they have to either rely on private cars or take public transit anyways.
- rcpt 5y agoWhich is kind of nuts considering that most people on those busses can't afford the South Bay houses they're commuting past. Otherwise there'd be no bus. disclaimer: the windows were shot out when I was riding the Google bus a couple years back
- seoaeu 5y agoEh, 20% of households in the Bay Area earn under $36k/year. Obviously shooting out bus windows isn't the right approach, but I think you may be underestimating just how much of a divide there is between even average tech workers and lower class people living in the region.
- rcpt 5y agoThe division between long time Californian landowning families and 20-something immigrant engineers somehow never comes up. Someone's whose been making 250k before taxes isn't poor by any stretch. But they're nowhere near affording a house in Mountain View, hence the busses.
- ghaff 5y ago>But they're nowhere near affording a house in Mountain View, hence the busses. The buses are because they want to live in the city rather than essentially suburban Mountain View. It's not like SF is cheap housing.
- seoaeu 5y agoI'm sorry but but a single person making nearly an order of magnitude more than a low income household in the same metro is more than just not poor. There is worlds of difference between not getting to live in the neighborhood you want compared to being severely rent burdened, having a horrible commute, and having to deal with a subpar living living situation in whatever handful neighborhoods have apartments remotely in your price range. Also, a quick glance at zillow listings looks to me like someone making $250k/year could easily afford to rent an apartment in Mountain View and would have a good shot at buying a cheaper condo there too. Sure buying a single family home might be out of reach, but it is hard to feel too much sympathy about that
- blo81 5y agoLeaving the Bay Area was worth it simply to avoid expending emotional energy on arguing about housing policy to this extent, particularly to unconsciously defend a decision to live there. Continuing to live there seems to condemn one to this attitude and approach to life, and life is way too short to have constant knife fights on HN over which major capitalist entity screws over homeless people harder (with some prejudice mixed in throughout the thread from working at one of them). Maybe the market just sucks at housing in general. Keep fighting about it instead of admitting the situation is hopeless, I guess, and those of us who know better will snap up the $160k four bedroom mansions until you figure it out.
- 01100011 5y agoMost of the people graduating in bay area cities are forever priced out of living in their hometowns already. Tech is largely to blame at this point because it fuels the extreme valuations. Without tech, prices would still be high because of lack of new supply for the growing population, but we left that price zone years ago.
- 34679 5y agoI don't think we should be pointing any fingers at locally employed people who purchase a home to live in while we're still allowing foreign investors to buy up multiple properties they'll never step foot in. >The percentage of California single-family homes bought in all-cash transactions has climbed in the past decade from 10 to 25 percent—and many of those are investors from Asia. https://calmatters.org/housing/2018/03/data-dig-are-foreign-investors-driving-up-real-estate-in-your-california-neighborhood/ https://calmatters.org/housing/2018/03/data-dig-are-foreign-...
- wumpus 5y agoPeople buy homes in Menlo Park with all cash because there will be multiple bidders and not being contingent on mortgage approval is the only way to win the bidding. Most of them then go and get a mortgage. The calmaters article has zero data about "investors from Asia". It's an assumption.
- erik_seaberg 5y agoThe median resident doesn't work in tech; even here we're only something like 15% of the population. It's mostly cash investors who don't necessarily live here that can sustain these prices, at least for the moment.