2 ms·
The fitness target isn't a stationary one. Larger heads might have been facilitated by a larger pelvic girdle (this seems to be the case in Neadnderthal skelet
by dredmorbius 5y ago
The fitness target isn't a stationary one.
Larger heads might have been facilitated by a larger pelvic girdle (this seems to be the case in Neadnderthal skeletons AFAIU), which is an adaptation which would enable large (and possibly inefficient) brains, but at a cost for bipedal mobility, speed, and/or efficiency.
Supposing a later competitor emerged with 1) smaller and 2) more effcicient brains as well as 3) narrower hips, then the previous advantage would become a (comparative) liability.
It's a bit like Clayton Chistensen's Innovator's Dilemma: evolving yourself (or your species) into a corner. Advantageous for a while, but ultimately maladaptive, and hard to back out of.
As with my other comments here, all but entirely conjecture.