6 ms·
I never quite understood why these ransom-ware attackers restrict themselves to a small subset of the MSP's clients. E.g.: The SolarWinds attack affected only s
by jiggawatts 5y ago
I never quite understood why these ransom-ware attackers restrict themselves to a small subset of the MSP's clients. E.g.: The SolarWinds attack affected only something like 1% of their customers, when it could easily have been 50% or more!
If you're evil and out for money, wouldn't you want to cast the widest net possible? Similarly, by encrypting a huge number of corporations concurrently, you'd "exhaust" the ability of a country to respond. There's only so many recovery specialists and IT contractors available to respond in an emergency. Encrypt only a few hundred targets and they can all recover. But if you encrypt a few hundred thousand, then there wouldn't be enough warm bodies available!
Thinking about it, I wonder if these attackers have set up permanent operations, with staff, payroll, and everything. Maybe they just to fly under the radar and collect a nice steady income instead of a risky but potentially huge one-time payoff...
- goatlover 5y agoYeah, I'm guessing they're going for steady income over risking a serious retaliation. If the hack is serious enough, there will be consequences.
- arthurcolle 5y agoFWIW though (and I don't have easily available "sources") there was this immediate retaliation where Biden was like "we will completely prosecute these offenders" and within days DarkSide PR department said "Hey sorry we didn't mean to disrupt core services, we just want money" (sic) So it's a spectrum
- covidthrow 5y agoThat's not even close to what happened. The administration left it alone for days saying they'll let private business sort it out. (Default investigation notwithstanding.) When a bunch of news media started reporting the group was Russian and then insinuate it was a state sponsored attack, DarkSide said something along the lines of, "We didn't realize this would start geopolitical conflict. We will be careful to vet clients more carefully in the future."
- astrange 5y agoDid they leave it alone for days? The FBI seized the ransom (claiming it was left in a Coinbase account) so clearly someone was doing something.
- Wolfenstein98k 5y ago"Left alone" as in publicly and geopolitically. The FBI investigated the crime as they always do. It was treated as a standard international monetary theft.
- whimsicalism 5y agoThey also accepted a ransom substantially below their typical going rate. The Darkside people were probably shitting their pants, this is not what they intended at all.
- arthurcolle 5y agoI mean it's reasonably close - but FWIW thanks for the correction, it's been a wild year
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- codeisawesome 5y agoSounds so spooky, do say more! Do you mean Jason Bourne / John Wick shows up at the hackers’ nest?
- draebek 5y agoOr Raytheon, yeah, I imagine so.
- rebuilder 5y agoWell, if the attacker manages to kill a few thousand people, there's precedent for the USA going to war over it. It would depend on the host nation of course, if it was e.g. China, Russia or some state in their sphere of influence, it'd be different than if the hackers were holed out in, say, Afghanistan.
- Donald 5y agoDarkSide's business model was to professionalize ransomware attacks with a dedicated professional services IT model, finance, and helpdesk support.
- readams 5y agoYou'd need to be able to process all the orders also. Every company needs support to pay the random and unlock. Also, at some point the military gets involved.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoYeah. If you take down 100 companies, it's crime. If you take down 100,000, it's an attack.
- raverbashing 5y agoCorrect, this won't get better until these groups are physically disbanded.
- ackbar03 5y agoIf i recall correctly solarwinds was more of an espionage operation by russia government actors. Their targets were mainly government agencies in US. The ransomware attack are from private profit-seeking groups, although I remember the head of REvil tweeted once he was neighbours with KGB's number two guy so you could argue the distinction is vague
- beermonster 5y agoAttribution is quite hard. When the 3-letter-agency tools leaked a few years ago, one of their leaked tools concerned deliberate false attribution. The solarwinds attack seemed to be about using a supply-chain attack to gain persistent access for recon and lateral movement. Pivot to Azure via Microsoft via SolarWinds software. Whomever it was tried to stay invisible for as long as possible. Once the game was up, they were not so careful about visible actions. RansomWare is more smash and grab though it's interesting/sad to see the current trends of Supply Chain attack prevalence and Ransomware attacks converge.
- beermonster 5y ago> when it could easily have been 50% or more! Was that down to slow patching cadence at 99% of companies? In which case those customers have different vulnerabilities to tend to.
- KirillPanov 5y agoAt some point you cross the threshold of "this is too much, drone them". Or send an assassin. Yes, even the United States does this occasionally. I suspect the attackers know this. Or else they aren't in it for the money. One or the other.
- rocqua 5y agoThe catchy rhyme being "warheads on foreheads".
- ahD5zae7 5y agoYeah unless they work from an office in e.g. Moscow. The US is powerful for sure but even they would think twice before droning a building in Moscow over some hacks, especially without concrete proof that's where they originated. At least I hope they would because if not then we may be closer to a world war than we thought...
- xwdv 5y agoSteady income is definitely the way to play. You don’t want to make a demand so large that there’s cheaper alternatives of dealing with you. Also you want the company to stay in business so it can continue generating revenue to extract future ransoms, and not have it lose a bunch of its customers from your repeated attacks.
- gonesilent 5y agoDidn't it only affect those who were unpatched hence the low percent? Current hack is 0-day.
- aj3 5y agoSolarwinds was distributed by a malicious patch (through legit channels). So all orgs were unpatched and in fact all got at least first stage downloaded (if they patched during that window).
- vsareto 5y agoTinfoil hat, but that Solarwinds access was way more valuable than a ransomware payoff. Made sense to keep quiet with it.
- jjk166 5y agoIt's not enough to just gain access - once you're in you need to compromise other defenses, you need to communicate your demand to the victim, you need to know how much to extort, you need to actually process the payment. Either you do this on a case by case basis or you take advantage of additional exploits that will only be viable for a subset of your potential targets, and this is all a race against time before someone notices your initial exploit. Either way, it's likely impractical for any non-nation state actor to simultaneously attack more than a few thousand targets in one go. This is combined with a business model resembling patent trolls: you want to extort just a little less than is worth fighting for. If a company gets hit on its own, it's probably not in a position to really do anything about it, but if there is some major hack affecting tons of companies, the odds of an actor with significantly more tech capability like the US government getting involved go way up, and suddenly fighting seems like a good option.
- wrycoder 5y agoMaybe you’re a state actor and a ransom demand, at least an overt one, is not your objective.
- cherryturnover 5y agoMy mind went there as well. Say I'm an affluent oligarch shorting major companies. I'd paying the ransom group to massively attack the company or various companies. Then cash out during the chaos.
- whimsicalism 5y agoYes, except for the fact that we don't hear about most of these attacks because both the attacker and attacked keep them quiet. That doesn't jive with your market manipulation hypothesis.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zaroth 5y agoBecause there are plenty of zero-days the NSA can deploy if you step out of your lane. It’s as much a political game at this point as anything. If anyone thinks they can hide behind cryptocurrency and hold truly strategic companies hostage they are deluding themselves. They’ll either end up hacked beyond their wildest imagination or facing literal hellfires. It’s brinkmanship. When the devs literally die, they think twice.
- Animats 5y agoAt some point, some nation-state will get annoyed enough to do something drastic. That's what ended state-sponsored terrorism. Or even a company. Uber's security chief once became annoyed with an attack from Nigeria. They traced the attack to an Internet cafe and sent some "lawyers" to talk to the attacker. Someone tried a ransomware attack on the Teamsters Union in 2019.[1] The FBI advised them to pay. The Teamsters didn't pay. There were no further attacks. The Teamsters declined to comment. (For those unfamiliar with American labor history, trying to push around the Teamsters Union usually ends badly for the pushers.) [1] https://thehill.com/policy/cybersecurity/558066-teamsters-refused-to-pay-a-ransomware-attack-in-2019 https://thehill.com/policy/cybersecurity/558066-teamsters-re...
- coolspot 5y agoYou make it sound like the Teamsters Union could do something bad to the attackers, so attackers gave up, but in reality Teamsters just rebuilt from archives, which was perhaps an economical decision: “Ultimately, the union decided not to pay the ransom based on advice from its insurance company, and instead rebuilt its systems based on archived materials, NBC reported.”
- Haddaway 5y agoMaybe a nation state is already behind it? https://cryptome.org/2021/06/Peck-Barb-1974.pdf https://cryptome.org/2021/06/Peck-Barb-1974.pdf Was Edward Snowdon "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1GtVt6quoD8&t=78s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1GtVt6quoD8&t=78s" or a psychologically manipulated patsy for the good/bad guys & girls? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full-spectrum_dominance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Full-spectrum_dominance isnt just about hacking a few computers, its about getting inside the brain of each and every one of us/you like a https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lG7DGMgfOb8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lG7DGMgfOb8. Or is this line of thought just a https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmin5WkOuPw&t=48s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmin5WkOuPw&t=48s ?
- aj3 5y agoSolarWinds affected 100% of installations that updated their deployments during that 8 month window. Your 1% comes from the ratio of networks that were specifically targeted and received 2nd stage with all the goodies. The reason why 2nd stage was only given to (relatively) small number of organizations - because the attack wasn’t ransomware, attackers didn’t have economical motives (in fact they were spooks on a government payroll). EDIT: I can’t spell
- nuker 5y ago> The SolarWinds attack affected only something like 1% of their customers, when it could easily have been 50% or more! If it was me (it was not), I’d use it to gain persistance in companies like Kaseya, extending my beachhead as first priority. After that is basically game over, cleaning it would take making new IT systems from scratch. And lets not forget firmware…
- ineedasername 5y agoGive it time, these are start-ups bootstrapping themselves. They don't have the support infrastructure in place yet to scale to beyond a few hundred companies. As it is, there are going to be a lot of over-worked people at REvil doing crunch time, missing family dinners and their kids' recitals and soccer games managing the logistics of this hack. No worries though, the ransom from this round should serve nicely as a Series B round of financing & enable rapid scaling of the post-hack ransom extraction process.
- aliyfarah 5y agoI wonder how much of a human element is involved in each individual hack. I would have thought the sticky note, encryption, payment & decryption was all automated.
- ljf 5y agoAs I understand it there is often a lot of discourse that takes place between the hacker and the hacked - agreeing prices, haggling, proof of files etc. Yes much can be automated but there is usually a human element to these deals and that costs the hackers money. They also want to be careful to limit their hacks to companies their handlers are happy for them to hack. Go too wide and you risk hitting a company directly or indirectly linked to your state/handler/patron.
- dredmorbius 5y agoYou'd think a GPT3 / GAN could be created to handle much of that. It's a percentages game anyway.
- whimsicalism 5y agoWhy would you want GPT to handle multi million dollar negotiations? Sorta playing into stereotypes about engineers here.
- 5y ago
- known 5y agoAnd I think Cloud computing is covertly 'leaking' vital data and has its role in ransom-ware attacks https://archive.is/x1Hvh https://archive.is/x1Hvh
- AtNightWeCode 5y agoI would not be surprised if there is a market for the tools and the knowledge. That the real hackers just sells it and then other people do the attacks and thereby taking the risk. Similar setups existed with botnets.
- miohtama 5y agoNote that i n the case of SolarWinds, there was no demands for ransoms. It was good old state level spying, not a job to get few bitcoins.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AtNightWeCode 5y agoI did write an answer before but now it seems like only Internet facing VSA servers are effected and some other measures may have stopped the attack. It could be all the servers they could find...