2 ms·
> Yelp and online business review sites provide value on the basis that you can make educated choices, but there is no choice involved with police. You don't ge
by heavyset_go 5y ago
> Yelp and online business review sites provide value on the basis that you can make educated choices, but there is no choice involved with police. You don't get to pick and choose which officers or departments are coming, and if someone calls the police on you you're not not going to be have the time or knowledge of who's being sent to search on RateOurCops before they get there. It's a fallacy.
You don't get to pick and choose your kid's public school teachers, either. You can extend this to public schools, as well. You don't choose public schools your kid goes to in the same way you don't get to choose what department in your city responds to your call. And yet Rate My Teachers exists for public school teachers[1] all the same.
You can choose where you live and decide what schools or teachers you don't want your kid being around, in the same way you can choose where you live or travel to in order to avoid certain cops or police departments entirely.
[1] https://ratemyteachers.com/ https://ratemyteachers.com/
- easterncalculus 5y agoYour argument is essentially that two wrongs make a right, since this other site exists then this one is fine. RatemyTeachers has a privacy policy and at least attempts to verify people, telling viewers that despite their efforts they should take reviews with a grain of salt[1]. Also, you still have more options for schools due to private and charter schools. It's still not an equal comparison. [1] https://ratemyteachers.com/faq https://ratemyteachers.com/faq
- heavyset_go 5y agoMy argument is that 1) you can, actually, make a choice using this information 2) that the OP isn't unique or different from other review sites, that in fact the OP is along the same lines of Rate My Professors, Rate My Teachers or other review sites. I also don't believe it's wrong, but I didn't argue that.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y ago> You don't get to pick and choose your kid's public school teachers, either Where I live you do. You can put in a request to have your child go to another school, either in your district or even out of your district. Or enroll them in private school, or charter school, or, heck, home school them. The difference is, doing this means you as a parent are on the hook for getting your child to these schools (and in the case of home school, teaching as well). But just because something is inconvenient doesn't mean it doesn't exist. And these options mean you can put your child where they will excel.
- heavyset_go 5y ago> But just because something is inconvenient doesn't mean it doesn't exist. And these options mean you can put your child where they will excel. Exactly. If I don't want to live or visit somewhere where I might encounter certain police officers or departments, I have the option of making that happen. And that option means my kid won't be on the wrong side of those particular people or departments abusing their power. Sites like the OP give people that option.