5 ms·
I'm not opposed to this to some degree. For example, software patents are ludicrous and IMO hard to intellectually honestly defend. Copyrights are great but nee
by kstrauser 5y ago
I'm not opposed to this to some degree. For example, software patents are ludicrous and IMO hard to intellectually honestly defend. Copyrights are great but need to be drastically shortened (life+70 is an abomination).
But trademarks have some customer-friendly properties: if I buy a soda with Coke's trademark design on it, I can be reasonably sure I'm buying an actual Coke product. OTOH, we also have the IOC suing people for using "Olympic" in the name of non-related businesses (eg https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150221/14095930099/olympics-committee-forces-oregon-restaurant-to-change-its-name.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150221/14095930099/olymp...), which should be a "too bad so sad" ruling for the defendant against anyone who names their organization after a physical location.
As an aside, I strongly believe that entities should have to pay taxes on their intellectual properties. It's at least imaginable that you could defend your real estate without the government's assistance, even if that means hiring armed people to enforce the borders you're claiming. It's impossible to enforce IP without the government's assistance, and I think it's utterly unreasonable to expect that government to lift a finger to help protect it without paying taxes on it. I ran this by Cory Doctorow and he patiently explained why this isn't possible, but I still contend that even if it can't be, it ought to be.
- tlholaday 5y agoDid Cory Doctorow's explanation address valuing intellectual property via Harberger taxes?
- kstrauser 5y agoIt didn't. The short version is that we don't currently have a wealth tax, with only a few specific kinds of things being taxable. I offered that maybe we could add IP to that list of things, and he said that this was the main gist of Piketty's plan and it had met with huge resistance, and that if we're going down that route we should probably start with stocks and bonds, etc.
- mixmastamyk 5y agoI'd like to see a copyright that was free for a reasonable amount of time, say 30 years then a fee starts at $10,000 on year+1 and doubles every year after.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoBecause a tax on IP is a tax on someone thoughts. What right do you or anyone else have to take a cut of someone's mind?
- kstrauser 5y agoWhat right does that person have to ask the government to defend their thoughts, which are provably thinkable by others, too?
- Dracophoenix 5y agoIf people had thought of it before, they would have filed first or proven they invented it first. In addition, people already pay filing fees for their patents, trademarks, and copyrights. Why should they have to pay more protection money to defend it?
- mcguire 5y agoThat would be one of the differences between "someone's thoughts" and IP.
- shkkmo 5y agoIt is absolutely not a tax on thoughts. It is a tax on a specifix ability to assert legal control over other people's thoughts.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoThat's what the filing fees are for. In addition, it's possible to have intellectual property without requiring government influence on someone's thoughts. Case in point, trade secrets.
- dantheman 5y agoTrademarks are radically different, they are an anti-fraud mechanism. If someone is trying to pass off a good as being produced by someone else, then it's fraud.
- tyingq 5y agoThat's what they are supposed to be. But you end up with Apple challenging a company's trademark, where the company has a recipe app with a pear fruit for a logo. https://www.macrumors.com/2020/08/08/legal-action-against-company-with-pear-logo/ https://www.macrumors.com/2020/08/08/legal-action-against-co...
- munk-a 5y agoJust because a law is being abused does it invalidate that law? Apple should absolutely get a bunch of fines for pursuing this enforcement if it is doing so in bad faith - or Prepear should be forced to alter it's image if it's found to be unfairly exploiting Apple's brand image. Also this case was resolved in a pretty reasonable manner[1] which actually does seem to increase the visual distinctiveness between the two logos and, from what I can tell, that logo change was the sole result of the settlement. Apple's logo is, IMO, three main things, an apple, a bite, and a leaf - and each of those is quite distinctively placed within the logo. Prepear was pretty precisely copying the style of the leaf. 1. https://www.creativebloq.com/news/apple-prepear-logo-resolution https://www.creativebloq.com/news/apple-prepear-logo-resolut...
- kube-system 5y agoIs there any remotely common legal construct for which a dubious case has never been brought?
- tyingq 5y agoThat was sort of my point. That it's not as simple as saying it's just anti fraud.
- 5y ago
- gpm 5y ago> if I buy a soda with Coke's trademark design on it, I can be reasonably sure I'm buying an actual Coke product. This always felt like something better enforced via fraud laws than intellectual property to me. Property is the wrong metaphor for trademarks. Right now you can do bullshit like sell and license trademarks, so I can't actually be confident that a FooBarWidget is made by FooBar. I can have some confidence that FooBar licensed there trademark for it, but they might be doing that as a way of cashing out on their reputation. That shouldn't be legal, that should be fraud. A better replacement would be special fraud laws against some set of phrases like "Made By <Company>" and "Certified By <Company>", and using those phrase when it's not the case should be very illegal. Maybe there should be a replacement version of trademarks where you can register a distinctive image or made up word as being synonyms with "Made By <Company>", but that shouldn't be sellable, licensable, or anything else, it should be a simple synonym. While <Company> should be able to sue for damages if they can show them, the real enforcement should come from law enforcement because the entities actually being lied to and defrauded are the customers, not <Company>.
- munk-a 5y agoI think you're essentially describing Trademark by another name. In the case of Coke there is a distinct styling and branding they use (red cursive lettering being a big component) as part of the brand they use to represent their company name. There are bound to be a whole bunch of edge cases here and so creating a registry process for trademarks to remove any danger from being an accidental look-alike actually ends up protecting small businesses. Those rights being saleable and licensable honestly just strikes me as common sense because CocaCola might want to empower regional bottling plants to produce their product without putting those bottling plant subsidiaries in the awkward position where they refuse to operate because at any moment CocaCola could step in and essentially seize their entire business since, contractually, there is no method to allow CocaCola to lease out the rights to make such styled bottles removing the protection from bottling plants. Lastly, CocaCola as a brand definitely has a large value to the company - so if that brand is not saleable how are you going to quantify that value and allow a transferrence of the value of it between different shareholders, holding companies, or company owners/executives. I also think you're oversimplifying damages - CocaCola could suffer a reputation loss due to CocoCola including arsenic in their product and causing public confusion. I think these portions of the law are pretty complicated - yes - but they're that way because it's a complicated subject.
- tshaddox 5y agoI’ve never understood why trademarks even get bunched in with intellectual property. Trademarks are a much simpler, easily-defensible concept. When you’re selling something you can’t lie about fundamental facts about the thing you’re selling.
- notahacker 5y agoBecause trademarks literally are intellectual property. They're words and designs and patterns that were designed by someone else but only laws can exclude people from using. Nothing necessarily dishonest about putting a swoosh designed by an employee of some other corporation on your bag to make it sell more, and nothing necessarily honest about putting words written by someone whose writing is more marketable than yours in a book they won't see any return on.
- mindslight 5y agoBecause "intellectual property" is not the basis of any law, but rather a post-hoc bundling of several disparate legal concepts (some reasonable and some not) in an attempt to cement all them as manifestly necessary.
- ajsnigrutin 5y ago> software patents are ludicrous and IMO hard to intellectually honestly defend. I'm not that opposed to software patents per-se, but I believe all patents (and copyright) should be much more time-limited. With software, a year or two would be a more reasonable (for me) time limit, and maybe 10 years for copyright.
- young_unixer 5y agoIn principle I'd agree with paying taxes for Intellectual Property, but there are problems: - Copyright is "automatic" whenever you fix a work to a medium. Should it be made manual, like patents? Or should copyright be exempt from taxes? What about Open Source? - Profitability for any given patent varies wildly depending on the company that owns it. So you'd end up with big corporations having patents because their scale (and profits) justifies owning patents, and small companies having no IP. Same thing for trademarks.
- kstrauser 5y agoThose are good questions to iron out. I think as a first approximation you could let the IP owner set their value, and assess taxes based on that. However, that would mean the owner couldn't sue for another larger amount if their rights are violated. Say you make a movie and claim that it's worth $10,000,000 for tax purposes. Well, you don't get to sue for $100,000,000 if someone pirates it, because you've already declared that it's not worth that much. I'm not persuaded by the "small companies have no IP" argument. Apple owns an enormous campus. My company doesn't. Is it fair that Apple gets to lay claim to a larger part of available real estate just because they can afford it? Well, yeah. I believe so, anyway.
- mcguire 5y ago"Apple owns an enormous campus. My company doesn't. Is it fair that Apple gets to lay claim to a larger part of available real estate just because they can afford it? Well, yeah. I believe so, anyway." The difference being that Apple cannot arbitrarily claim to own your real estate. If you create a work that is worth a great deal, but cannot claim it to have that value because you cannot afford to pay the taxes (yet), a large organization can safely appropriate that work while only paying the smaller amount of damages. Hm; one question: Could they then claim that it is their work, put a large value on it, and put you out of business?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- catern 5y ago