5 ms·
> Disputes between inventors, creators, authors, artists, businesses, and other such entities should be resolved without government intervention. How? Is putti
by zdw 5y ago
> Disputes between inventors, creators, authors, artists, businesses, and other such entities should be resolved without government intervention.
How? Is putting IP disputes in the court system "without government intervention?"
As much as I would like to see an IP holders version of Robot Jox, I'd imagine this would turn into a "whoever has more money wins".
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> How? Is putting IP disputes in the court system "without government intervention?" Assume they’re advocating for some sort of arbitration system.
- munk-a 5y agoOh awesome - so instead of an organization that is (sorta) held accountable to the public via elections we'd just let private organizations run the whole show?
- shadowfox 5y agoLibertarianism tends to skew that way, often. So I wouldn't say it is surprising in the case, whether we agree or not.
- munk-a 5y agoI can't speak for all Libertarians and I'm not one myself - so don't take this as a blanket statement but, from my impression, a lot of Libertarians in the US support private alternatives to public services and private services as a first line of treatment. Advocating that IP claims should be forced to fail in private arbitration before being eligible for a hearing in public court is a reasonable way to prioritize the private market fixing problems on the cheap before consuming public resources - but removing the courts as the ultimate arbiter is a really big shift in my mind.
- notJim 5y agoThat would work if there's a contract in place, but if IP rights are abolished entirely, what is there to arbitrate? I got a hold of your song and you don't like it? Well it was never "yours" in the first place.
- mcguire 5y agoTechnically, you could presumably have a contract with someone who has a contractual obligation to secure the work---you could request arbitration with that someone for that breach of contract. But yeah, if you did something stupid like playing your song in public and someone got a recording, you are screwed. If your work is important or valuable to you, keep it under lock and key.
- nkrisc 5y agoWithout government intervention, how would anyone be compelled to participate in arbitration?
- mcguire 5y agoNot forcefully: "...we support the prohibition of the initiation of physical force against others..." They could talk at you until you cease resisting.
- tablespoon 5y ago> Assume they’re advocating for some sort of arbitration system. Without IP laws, how would one party force the other into arbitration? Or to be more specific, if I spend two years writing an excellent novel but Random House legally makes all the money off it it with a pirate edition, why would they enter arbitration with me? They'd just say "get lost," and laugh all the way to the bank.
- mcguire 5y agoBecause of the inherently good nature of humanity, the basis of Libertarian assumptions. P.S. Do note that the platform of the Libertarian Party of Colorado explicitly denies that the government has a monopoly on violent force, does not allow the government to initiate violence, and in fact, doesn't describe any way of paying for what force the government may legitimately apply. Enforcing any of your rights requires you to be a part of a more powerful gang than theirs.
- notJim 5y agoObviously you would raise an army to invade Random House and force them to recognize your claim. If you yourself don't have the funds to hire a sufficient number of mercenaries, what you'd have to do is find a local patron and convince them that they should support you for various reasons. Most likely in this case, you'd have to promise them a significant share of the royalties. Assuming you manage to convince your patron(s), they would then assemble their army and fight Random House's army. If successful on the battlefield, congratulations! I can already feel the Liberty.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Without IP laws, how would one party force the other into arbitration? Contractually. (Non-participants wouldn’t be subject.)
- tablespoon 5y ago>> Without IP laws, how would one party force the other into arbitration? > Contractually. (Non-participants wouldn’t be subject.) So the "arbitration" mechanism would be useless in almost all relevant circumstances and is not a serious suggestion.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kgwxd 5y agoA fight over intellectual property can only be resolved in a battle of intellect. Perhaps an arrangement can be reached? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZSx3zNZOaU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZSx3zNZOaU
- young_unixer 5y agoWell, they wouldn't be IP disputes, because there would be no IP. I'm guessing they refer to signing contracts similar to NDAs when you don't want your invention to be public, but still want to "sell" it to some specific entity. Those of us that don't want to be bound by any "IP" can just not sign any of those contracts.
- mcguire 5y agoNote that, historically, that was kind of the state prior to the invention of "intellectual property". That state has ... issues.
- munificent 5y ago> I'd imagine this would turn into a "whoever has more money wins". That's not too far from the libertarian ethos.