5 ms·
Few people have ever, in fact, read the law. Doing so often reveals amazing opportunities. In this case, he looked into what the legal status of a home is when
by ctdonath 15y ago
Few people have ever, in fact, read the law. Doing so often reveals amazing opportunities.
In this case, he looked into what the legal status of a home is when the mortgage paying owner abandons it, and the mortgage company ceases to exist. Answer: nobody owns it, and whoever files paperwork and actually starts living there gets it. Go figure.
To those saying "pay the $300,000!": to whom? The homeowner? he gave up ownership by moving out and abandoning the mortgage payments. The mortgage company actually owns the house until it's paid off, but if the company goes defunct then nobody owns it. There is nobody to pay!
- tptacek 15y agoWhat? No. That's not what happened. It's not "nobody owns it". When your mortgage company folds, the titles don't vanish into the ether. The titles have economic value, even in the (extraordinarily unlikely) case where that value is pennies on the original dollar. The assets of the mortgage company are sold. Meanwhile, this is a terrible outcome for the neighborhood. Many people on HN are no doubt failing to find ways to shed tears for mortgage companies, but during the 10+ (note carefully that "plus" sign) years this guy's BS claim to the house takes to resolve itself, the house is out of the market; it can't be sold to anyone, at any price. It must instead be occupied by someone who has virtually no incentive to maintain or improve it.
- Despite 15y agoIs the guy living there now? Seems he would have the same incentives as any owner. I don't see why the neighborhood cares at all, or why anyone should care what the neighbors think.
- dctoedt 15y ago> Is the guy living there now? Seems he would have the same incentives as any owner. My brother owns rent houses; from the stories he tells, he would disagree even about renters, let alone squatters. And recall the quote attributed to Lawrence Summers: In the history of the world, no one has ever washed a rented car. [1] [1] http://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/06/21/wash-rental/ http://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/06/21/wash-rental/
- haberman 15y ago> In the history of the world, no one has ever washed a rented car. It's funny, my brother did that just last week. It was extremely muddy from when he got it stuck in the middle of a pasture.
- kragen 15y ago> And recall the quote attributed to Lawrence Summers: In the history of the world, no one has ever washed a rented car. [1] Man, I'm sure glad Lawrence Summers doesn't go to Burning Man. But if he did, it sounds like his entire worldview would be destroyed.
- honopu 15y agoI have washed a rented car, but then again I was 25, my dad gave me the skymiles, I was off in the foreign land of Kaua'i Hawaii and I didn't want to have to pay the cleaning fee, so i deemed the $4 potentially worth it. Then again I am a bit older, arguably a bit wiser, and I haven't even considered cleaning a rental car since then.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoMy family owned a renthouse, and yes, it's awful. But the renters aren't planning on becoming owners of the house - this guy is.
- Despite 15y agoI admittedly don't know anything about squatters -- but if you were going to squat in order to own a house, why would you treat it like a rental? You're trying to take ownership, you would treat it like it was yours. There must be some aspect to this that you all know about but I'm missing.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Natsu 15y agoHopefully the real owners will figure out that they've got a squatter and will evict him. But if it actually takes them more than ten years to figure out that someone else is living in their house, even when this has hit the national news, just how well can they be maintaining the property? You'd think they would notice the problem the first time they cut the grass.
- ruby_on_rails 15y agoLOL A) It not being the the ,market holds the greatest benefit for everybody that matters, as everyone else's home prices rise as a result of one less home being sold. B) There is a $500,000 home at the end of my block. A mortgage company (which is still in business) owns it. Still they don't maintain it. The pool is decaying into a bacteria ridden cess pool and everyone living here takes turns calling the mortgage company just to get them to mow what are usually 4' high grass out front. I imagine that this situation is prevalent elsewhere as well. I would love it if one of the neighbors could obtain the house for free and keep it up. Speaking of, good job assuming that this guy "owning" it is somehow not keeping it up. Stereotypes will get you far. I can't way to read what you say when it turns out this guy is not only poor, but black or muslim so you can think even less of him.
- pavel_lishin 15y ago> I would love it if one of the neighbors could obtain the house for free and keep it up. Why don't you do it?
- knieveltech 15y ago"Meanwhile, this is a terrible outcome for the neighborhood." Care to quantify that? No indication was made in the article that this guy is (for example) stacking junk cars in the front yard with a forklift, throwing all-night keggers, practicing his drum solos at 3:00am or setting up a meth lab in an unused bedroom. So how, exactly, is the neighborhood impacted? Hell, if he mows the yard that's a net gain...
- forgottenpaswrd 15y agoA lesson from Economy 101: A company goes defunct when their debt obligations grow bigger than what the company is worth. It is said that "liabilities are bigger than asserts" on the balance sheet: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balance_sheet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balance_sheet So if the company can not pay its debt, the company is given to its debtors. So THERE IS ALWAYS SOMEONE WHO OWNS the house, those that expended the money for the house to be built and own the debt. Odds are that the $300.000 is worth $100.000 in the open market today(if they want to recoup the investment) and they will loose money but it is not $0 or $16.
- kragen 15y agoYou mean "to its unsecured creditors," not to its debtors. And actually, during bankruptcy, the company's assets are conveyed to a trustee, not directly to the creditors; the trustee pays the creditors the proceeds of the sale of the assets. And you're mistaken about when bankruptcy happens; a company can have a negative book value (assets minus liabilities) indefinitely as long as none of its creditors goes unpaid and files a (successful) bankruptcy petition against it as a result. It is less common, but certainly not unheard of, for bankruptcy petitions to be filed against companies with positive book values. (The company might be badly mismanaged, or it might have a lot of its book value tied up in illiquid assets it can't find a buyer for.) Given this litany of errors, you ought not be offering the rest of us "lessons from Econom[ics] 101" and posting sentences in all capital letters. Now then, I believe that in Texas law, and in the common law in general, you cannot abandon title to land. However, that is not the case for many other assets; if a company abandons some chattel property, before or after entering bankruptcy, the bankruptcy trustee does not gain the right to sell that property. Also, under civil law, which is in effect over much of the world (although not in Texas), title to land can indeed be abandoned. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1348211 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1348211