4 ms·
I agree, but this does raise one question for me. If we are to eat mindfully, should we not have pets at all? This seems to be a population, resource, and globa
by giantg2 5y ago
I agree, but this does raise one question for me. If we are to eat mindfully, should we not have pets at all? This seems to be a population, resource, and global warming constraint.
- silicon2401 5y agoUnpopular opinion, but I would completely outlaw any pet ownership or animal husbandry on the simple basis that it's impossible for animals to consent to being owned.
- chacha2 5y agoThey didn't consent to nature either.
- Falling3 5y agoAnd that's why we don't use "but Nature did it first" as a justification in moral discussions.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI think that's too simplistic. Here's an animal. The options are: - Owned/managed by a human - Living in nature - Not existing The animal has consented to exactly none of those. But living in nature is not a bed of roses. Is it moral to subject an animal to that? In that analysis, human ownership (if humane) seems like the most moral option. And "nature did it first" has nothing to do with the analysis.
- Falling3 5y agoI disagree it's too simplistic. It's a logical fallacy that we wouldn't be advocating for in any other context than our treatment of non-human animals. It's also just a disingenuous argument. If our actual concern were the welfare and lives of animals in the wild, we would be capturing and caring for those individuals - not breeding new ones into existence.
- giantg2 5y agoEven humane ownership generally implies reproductive restrictions. I don't see how that could be considered the most moral option.
- snug 5y agoNeither did a child being born
- giantg2 5y agoNor do any of us have the real option to consent or withdraw consent to living in the society we are born into (assuming emmigration is not an option, or that the alternatives are no better)
- LikelyClueless 5y agoWhat do you think about cooperative hunting between humans and dogs? Not the same as modern domestication, but some have theorized dogs may have domesticated themselves by eating scraps and/or leaving scraps progressing into sharing, hunting and training with humans. These relationships could have slowly progressed to human ownership of dogs. If we gloss over the hunting ethics, where would you draw the line for when this ethical cooperation between unequal partners turns unethical? Or do you reject the premise?
- danboarder 5y agoIf people separate themselves from nature and do not have personal friendship and daily interaction with animals, I think it is more difficult to care about them generally, based on the social rule of "statistical numbing" where studies have shown that we care more about individual creatures that we know something about than groups that we don't (1,2). (1) https://bigthink.com/risk-reason-and-reality/statistical-numbing-why-millions-can-die-and-we-dont-care https://bigthink.com/risk-reason-and-reality/statistical-num... (2) https://www.ibtimes.com/why-we-care-more-about-death-lion-thousand-dead-children-2032381 https://www.ibtimes.com/why-we-care-more-about-death-lion-th...
- giantg2 5y agoBut then the better solution is to have the people interact with useful animals, like service animals or agricultural animals. Pets would be superfluous when there are other animals that could provide interactions and another useful purpose. This would be a more efficient use of resources and more climate friendly.
- warent 5y agoI'm not sure how you got this conclusion, it seems like the exact opposite of what they're saying. Placing animals in buckets of "useful" and "useless" is not empathy; that's back to the point of treating them like tools or exploitable resources. Love and empathy is not intended to be conditional on what value you can reap from it. At best that's a business relationship, and at worst it's something very dark.
- giantg2 5y ago"...treating them like tools or exploitable resources." Everything is a resource regardless of whether it is exploited. The person saying empathy comes from having exposure to pets is in essence saying pets are a resource to cultivate empathy and should be exploited as such. The issue is resource constraints. Pets consume a lot of argicultural and pharmaceutical resources. You talk of love and empathy being unconditional, but when you live in a resource constrained world, should we spend money creating, housing, and feeding pets? Or should we care for the vulnerable humans? Should we stop keeping pets so that we don't need the agriculture that is required to support them, thus feeding people or allowing the land to return to the natural world and it's native animals? Resources are a part of the equation. It seems many people ignore the n-order impacts. It's the same as people buying their processed food or meat without ever seeing the source and process. Probably even more so with kibble since it doesn't look like food to us.
- ssijak 5y agoAdopt stray animals, dont buy.
- summm 5y agoAnd do not show them off, in order not to entice others to buy.