2 ms·
More essentially (IMHO), it's not a claim of fact that originates with the speaker. It's commentary on a publicly disclosed set of facts ("contents of the BBC s
by perihelions 5y ago
More essentially (IMHO), it's not a claim of fact that originates with the speaker. It's commentary on a publicly disclosed set of facts ("contents of the BBC show that aired on Feburary 3"), that both writer and readers are familiar with.
In the US at least, it's categorically impossible for this fact pattern to be defamatory -- regardless if the claims are true or false. You can't tortiously mislead an intelligent person by discussing a TV program *that you've both watched*.