4 ms·
The frugal little wouldn't lose anything. They'd gain less, which is not the same. Every single day there are people taking really stupid risks and winning due
by viraptor 5y ago
The frugal little wouldn't lose anything. They'd gain less, which is not the same. Every single day there are people taking really stupid risks and winning due to luck. Do you feel penalised because you took less risks?
If cancelling student debt solves real problems for the population on average, but makes a few idiots multimillionaires by accident... I'm all for it.
- errantmind 5y agoWhere do you think the money comes from to pay off this debt? The debt doesn't just disappear into thin air
- TheCraiggers 5y agoI'm out of my depth here; if I'm wrong I would love to be educated. My assumption is that the debt holders would be the ones losing. I don't know about you, but I don't hold any person's medical or education debt. In my estimation, these are ultimately all held by the rich and powerful fat cats- owners of banks, etc.
- EvanAnderson 5y agoThe vast majority of student loan debt in the US is owned by the federal government. The "fat cats" who will be stuck holding the bag are the taxpayers.
- TheCraiggers 5y agoThanks. I just looked and yup, 92 of student loans are owned by the government. That seems.... very bad for all sorts of reasons.
- D13Fd 5y agoNo. We all end up paying, because the student loan debt they are talking about cancelling is ultimately held by the federal government. We'd be taking things from the bucket of "the people who borrowed have to pay it back" and putting it into the bucket of "we all have to pay it back through increased taxes."
- wombatpm 5y agoWhat if the deal for debt cancellation was a 5% tax increase for those whose debt was cancelled for the remainder of their lives? Whenever you calculate tax, forgiven debtors pay 5% more.
- JamesBarney 5y agoIt's solely U.S. government. Any discussed debt cancellation never included private loans. And if it did, the U.S. government would pay off the holder of the private loan, not just cancel the debt.
- viraptor 5y agoIndirectly from taxes. However the context here / the premise of the article is that the one off payment is worth it in exchange for long-term boost in the economy and freeing people from obligations holding them back.
- gruez 5y ago>Every single day there are people taking really stupid risks and winning due to luck. Do you feel penalised because you took less risks? Yes, actually. If people were YOLOing away their savings on DOGE and meme stocks and the government picked up the tab, but the responsible passive investors like me got no assistance because I didn't experience any losses, I'd be pretty mad.
- JamesBarney 5y agoAll cancelling student loans does is transfer money from the college educated to the non-college educated. And student loans can already be put on thirty year plan, or setup for income based repayment. No one is starving because of their student loans, they're just having to purchase a house a little later in life than if they didn't borrow a bunch of money.