5 ms·
> In production, they think a system built to serve the needs of a family might be built for around $100. I think this is much more important to a great many p
by jeroenhd 5y ago
> In production, they think a system built to serve the needs of a family might be built for around $100.
I think this is much more important to a great many people than the theoretical efficiency of reverse osmosis. Percentages greater than 100% always do well in media reports about these topics, but they're not necessarily the point of the exercise. If the goal was to produce a system that's as efficient as possible, the researchers wouldn't have used household-style supplies but more expensive, advanced materials.
Reverse osmosis is great for a central area such as a large city in a place with reliable distribution, but in many places around the world, an independent, affordable system that can turn seawater into drinking water for a family or two has much more value.
- londons_explore 5y agoNothing about reverse osmosis can't be scaled down in size or cost. The actual membranes are $9 for enough for 100 gallons per day (retail prices, [1]). High pressure pumps and hoses scale linearly. Solar panels scale linearly. Filters scale linearly. In fact, using this solar fountain [2] as the basis for the design, and switching the pump impeller for a high pressure version, and the nozzle for an RO membrane and hose, you immediately have a drinking water machine for a few people for $20. The fountain already has a pre-filter built in. [1]: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32669709750.html https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32669709750.html [2]: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002883892948.html https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002883892948.html
- SiempreViernes 5y agoAh, so what you are saying is that this is already deployed on a large scale to solve distributed water issues?
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoWhat he’s actually saying is he found some residential grade nonsense from China that only seems economically feasible because of the slave labor and subsidized transport.
- kortex 5y agoI have first-hand experience that a) you need positive displacement pumps of a certain quality and power for RO and the cheap Ali ones self-destruct in minutes/hours b) you still need housing, plumbing, receptacles, etc c) fouling is a non-trivial issue. Expect to pay around $300 minimum for a small RO solar plant, and a couple bucks a month for upkeep. And logistics. Granted that's USA prices (upstate NY, not SV) but that prices out a lot of developing regions.
- londons_explore 5y agoFouling can be dramatically reduced by putting a small electrical current through the saltwater, freeing Chlorine ions which quickly kill biological things before they can adhere to your membrane. That combined with reverse flow flushing will probably last many years. And it can all be controlled by a 10 cent microcontroller, one pump, one valve, and a pressure sensor. I don't doubt that high pressure pumps are bad... but that's just a design issue - there is nothing theoretically expensive about them.
- kortex 5y agoHeh, this is reminiscent of the infamous HN dropbox comment. Free chlorine (technically assorted chlorine oxides like hypochlorite) attacks RO membranes, so now you have to deactivate your reactive species first. Usually UV lamps, you use sun, but now you need UV-clear tubing, not easy. Reverse flow flushing can be done with the components you mention, that's another $20/50 plus sourcing logistics. Yes, the theoretical expense in quality pumps is quality. There are tighter tolerances, beefier components, better polymers, and more QA. It all adds up. It's still all fairly cheap by Western standards, but it's a tall ask for a lot of places that barely have potable water.
- jkqwzsoo 5y agoCommercial RO membranes (based on the poly(m-phenylenediamine trimesic acid), a.k.a. polyamide) chemistry have zero tolerance to free chlorine and will rapidly degrade under such conditions. The chlorine tolerance is listed as “nil” on many manufacturer’s spec sheets. Even using tap water on a polyamide membrane without some kind of prefilter (like GAC) will cause noticeable reduction in both the permeance and rejection of the membrane. There was a big push towards developing chlorine-resistant chemistries a few years ago, but as far as I can tell, that has fallen into a “researchers don’t know what they’re doing, the plants are already designed around this problem” narrative. Of course, those plants are huge investments, and maybe it’s correct that one wouldn’t be able to take advantage of chlorine-resistant membranes until a new plant was built. Cellulose triacetate RO membranes have chlorine tolerance, but have inferior chemical stability, productivity and selectivity to polyamide membranes, so it is sometimes used where chlorine tolerance is an issue. CTA membranes are also available in hollow fiber format, while polyamide membranes are essentially exclusively found in spiral wound configuration (some operators want fibers for higher fouling/solids feed). CTA is limited to a much smaller pH window (like 4-6 versus 2-12), and are not suitable for more aggressive cleaning methods, so I’m not sure if it overall provides a benefit versus polyamide RO with more aggressive cleaning cycles.