4 ms·
It's somewhat surprising for a radio amateur group to take it upon themselves to complain to the FCC about interference to a whole bunch of infrastructure-criti
by ridaj 5y ago
It's somewhat surprising for a radio amateur group to take it upon themselves to complain to the FCC about interference to a whole bunch of infrastructure-critical systems like satellite positioning, air traffic control, etc. Sounds a bit like spectrum vigilantism to me. Or was there actual harm done to these systems? You'd hope that if it was really critical there'd be more investigations by the government vs waiting for private groups to complain.
- tibbetts 5y agoThis is kind of what the ARRL does. Amateur radio is supposed to be self-policing. They want to minimize FCC headaches from any kind of hobbyist radio, in order to maintain flexibility and tolerance.
- vvanders 5y agoNot really surprising, radio only works if we all play by the rules. Even a small 5w transmitter up high enough can easily cover over 100 miles. Most radio groups tend to be disaster recovery and communication adjacent so they care about infrastructure even if it's not directly on the ham bands.
- wrs 5y agoMaking an official complaint to the appropriate government enforcement agency is the exact opposite of “vigilantism”. Vigilantism would be hams deliberately crashing the drones with jammers, or something.
- bombcar 5y agoHams have done just that - famously chasing the Russian woodpecker iirc off of frequencies they wanted to use.
- djmips 5y agoFor those curious I located the relevant wiki information. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duga_radar#Jamming_the_Woodpecker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duga_radar#Jamming_the_Woodpec.... There is no reference to the jamming being successful however.
- mnouquet 5y ago> Making an official complaint to the appropriate government enforcement agency is the exact opposite of “vigilantism”. You're right, it's straight delation.
- Johnythree 5y agoTo have any hope of keeping the ham frequency allocations, hams MUST be self policing and vigilant.
- justin66 5y ago> It's somewhat surprising for a radio amateur group to take it upon themselves to complain to the FCC... Sounds a bit like spectrum vigilantism to me. Surprising? Have you met any hams?
- anilakar 5y agoSomeone dumps their garbage on your front yard. You hop in your car, follow them and find out that they're running a large-scale illegal garbage dumping business. You call the cops and report both crimes. Are you a "vigilante" now?