4 ms·
As someone who's done a ton of academic research in emotions, I just want to point out: Lisa Feldman Barrett's theory of emotions (which this article uses) is
by crazygringo 5y ago
As someone who's done a ton of academic research in emotions, I just want to point out:
Lisa Feldman Barrett's theory of emotions (which this article uses) is widely considered implausible by emotions researchers, but she's gotten a surprising amount of media coverage that presents her theories as consensus or fact.
In a nutshell: traditional "appraisal theory" says for example, we appraise something as dangerous (a bear), and have an emotion that consists of bodily and mental feelings (fear), and that emotions are inbuilt much like colors are. (You can't choose to see red as blue).
What Barrett argues is that seeing a bear produces adrenaline -- a feeling which precedes emotion -- and then we can interpret that adrenaline feeling however we like, that emotions are essentially cultural constructions or labels we've invented that we're free to uninvent.
However, this view, besides defying common sense, simply isn't consistent with data. Emotions follow regular patterns in what generates them (e.g. a dangerous situation creates fear) and what relieves them (e.g. escaping a dangerous situation allows fear to subside). There's zero evidence we can reinterpret or redefine our emotions by will, as she suggests. (Nor can she account for why infants all share the same emotional patterns, before they could have learned them culturally.)
If you really want to get into current academic theories of emotion (and Ctrl+F for "Barrett" to see where she sits), you can basically start here:
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/emotion/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/emotion/
- MathYouF 5y agoI watched an interview with her on YouTube and she had a very argumentative tone when questioned by an audience member, rather than a conversational and educational one. Not surprised to hear from a fellow expert that her theories aren't really supported by evidence. She seemed extremely defensive during the Q&A. Here's the video: https://youtu.be/qwsft6tmvBA https://youtu.be/qwsft6tmvBA In fact the audience member I linked to basically accidentally stepped on a landmine which seems to be the main critique you've posted of her work, just by talking about facts that seem evident (that emotions are the result of chemicals flooding the brain)
- smeej 5y agoDo you know of any studies where this has been studied in autistic people? For me, the gap between physical reaction and identifying an emotion can sometimes be very long, like days or longer. Because I don't identify my emotions intuitively, I actually have to sit and look at the physical symptoms to figure out what the emotion was. My heart was racing and I felt queasy in my stomach. Did something about him scare me and I should be wary, or am I attracted to him? I can't always tell. Sometimes it does seem like I could choose. Like as a kid, I thought I had really bad stage fright, until someone said maybe I was actually excited. It was an easy shift. Now I love speaking in front of people, and I do it easily. But were they right and just identifying my emotions better than I was? Or was I actually afraid and, by thinking of those same physical symptoms as excitement, did I become excited? I'm fascinated to find out this has been studied and people have theories leading toward actual answers!
- crazygringo 5y agoUnfortunately emotion in autistic people isn't an area I've researched, so I can't help you there specifically. But with the rest of what you're saying, I can say a few things in response. First, that plenty of people don't identify their emotions intuitively at all, that's not something necessarily autistic. In fact, it's why the whole field of "educational intelligence" education exists. You're describing a classic case of high arousal that is very common to take quite a bit of life experience and feedback to be able to accurately interpret the emotion you're feeling. But also, emotions are often mixed -- it's easy to be attrated to someone but also scared, whether scared of them directly, or scared of the attraction, or scared of the strong feeling period -- or scared in multiple ways, and then one goes away but another continues! And as for the second example of stage fright, there are three things I can say. The first is the common adage "if it's mentionable it's manageable" -- in therapy, simply being able to recognize and name an emotion allows us to live with it in a healthy balance rather than be dominated by it. For some people, understanding that stage fright is normal anxiety that operates within certain expected parameters and a healthy response is enough to be able to speak comfortably. Indeed, if you weren't nervous at all, that would show you didn't care -- so a certain level of anxiety is expected and good. Second, actors specifically are often told, if nervous, to imagine that their character is nervous, and so rather than to fight against nervousness or stage fright, to use it to their advantage -- and indeed most acting scenes are "high stakes" so it works well. And so third, what your friend told you was great advice. Anxiety and excitement aren't exactly the same thing, but simply by recognizing and validating your emotional arousal and framing it as a positive thing (regardless of its label), they essentially accomplished the previous two things I described -- that it's a positive emotion (it means you care), and energy you can use to your advantage (because it's appropriate). So in other words, you were probably feeling anxiety and excitement, but the simple message of "it's OK and good what you're feeling" kept anxiety at a reasonable normal level that doesn't interfere, and really that low-level anxiety is essentially healthy heightened attention appropriate to the situation. Hope that all makes sense!
- vintermann 5y agoThat we can reinterpret our emotions by will I agree is fairly silly, and seems like more like the thing one would believe if one wants to sell self-help books. But this doesn't rule out that emotional responses are early, learned scaffolding on raw internal cues that we couldn't reliably distinguish without context. That all babies seem to learn e.g. fear and laughter in a similar way doesn't contradict that. We could just all be pushed by our circumstance to learn in a similar same way. And more darkly, we may not quite all learn basic emotional resposes in the same way. Reading about people growing up in abusive relationships, and e.g. returning to an abusive spouse I've often wondered, does the person here described literally confuse fear and affection?