19 ms·
> But the odds that a communist party leader's speech is going to lead to an intellectually curious discussion from the front page of Hacker News are statistica
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
> But the odds that a communist party leader's speech is going to lead to an intellectually curious discussion from the front page of Hacker News are statistically zero
That's a very reductive and oriented political statement.
This happens to be a speech by the leader of one of the major powers on this planet. It is also full of historical and cultural references.
At the very least an attempt to understand his and China's point of view should be intellectually interesting and may lead to a better understanding among people of different cultures.
I agree with your point that any attempt to discuss this would lead to flame wars and drown any interesting comments. This is unfortunately the state of things on HN. Nonetheless, I feel that dismissing the submission on the basis that it is from a "communist party leader" lacks intellectual curiosity and is, as said, a political and preconceived opinion.
- dang 5y agoI don't care that it's by a communist party leader. The point is that it will just trigger the more triggerable internet people. Speeches by leaders of major powers are generally off topic on HN. They all make them all the time. It takes a subtle and experienced eye to read anything interesting in them. More importantly, this is not a geopolitics site. A 100th anniversary speech is arguably a little less garden-variety, but then again, arguably not - there's always some historical event at hand to tie the latest speech to, and the latest speech is always about the geopolitics of the present. I don't see how this is in any way a controversial call. Biden speeches and Putin speeches aren't on topic here either, barring something super unusual.
- mytailorisrich 5y ago> I don't care that it's by a communist party leader. Then don't make a specific point of it, because your previous statement makes it sound like you do care. "Speeches by leaders of major powers are generally off topic on HN" would have done the job.