5 ms·
"if you have to shut down your company, that's fine, but do it properly -- pay your bills, pay your employees in full, do it in an orderly fashion -- if you do,
by tluyben2 15y ago
"if you have to shut down your company, that's fine, but do it properly -- pay your bills, pay your employees in full, do it in an orderly fashion -- if you do, I'll invest in you again, otherwise I won't." => sometimes you don't have this luxury; this is easy if you are bought out and the new company wants to kill (a part of) your bought business, but if the bank is just pulling the rug from under you, you usually don't have the luxury to pay your bills, pay your employees in full etc, let alone do stuff orderly.
- rdl 15y agoRight, that is why you plan ahead and keep a buffer. You shut down when there is enough cash left to meet obligations, not after you've spent every last cent. This is for externally funded startups, not bootstrapped. If it is bootstrapped, I think it is ok to dig deeper (but not actually committing major crimes or putting your health or safety St risk), but for a funded company, you should probably either wind things down in an orderly way, or at least fire everyone and pay all all salaries, pay vendors, and then switch back to bootstrap mode.
- true_religion 15y ago> Right, that is why you plan ahead and keep a buffer. If every company planned ahead and kept a buffer, then no companies would go bankrupt. They would simply terminate services, and everyone would get paid what they were owed.
- pushingbits 15y agoWouldn't that be nice?
- tptacek 15y agoIn most of the companies you've heard of going bankrupt, the company made payroll. Obviously, they then laid off a crap-ton of people. But what we're talking about here --- in a huge digression from what's happening with The Fridge, by the way --- is the notion of startups that run past their ability to meet payroll obligations, say "oh well we tried, good thing the valley is so tolerant of failure", and bounce checks to employees.
- true_religion 15y agoThat by the way isn't what I was talking about. You can make your payroll obligation, then declare bankruptcy in the face of creditors. That's usually what happens--people take on short term debt to keep afloat, and use it to pay off their employees as they wait for the "big contract" to clear. The contract doesn't clear in time, and everything collapses. At this point, they're bankrupt and though some creditors might get paid from the sale of office furniture and computers----not all of them will see all of their money. The Op suggested that even these companies should never be given a second chance.
- rdl 15y agoIt's more important that the founders (or executives) conduct an orderly shutdown (vs. just locking the doors and not responding to email), than that every possible creditor be paid in full. There should be an explicit seniority in debt or other liabilities. Even when there isn't, I think there is some clear standard of fairness (individuals get paid first, including refunding prepaid customer funds, and convertible notes get paid last. Vendors who have already provided service should probably get paid before continuing to pay on things like the balance of long-term leases; there are legal standards and best practice for all of this, although it probably varies by jurisdiction). The only really bad thing is burning unknowing employees, especially after misleading them about finances.
- edw519 15y agoyou usually don't have the luxury to pay your bills, pay your employees in full etc, let alone do stuff orderly. Make not mistake about it: paying your bills and paying your employees in full are not luxuries, they are requirements. Grandparent didn't say you have to do it now, just that you have to do it. Anyone who hides behind "market conditions", "the bank", "unrecoverable errors in judgment", or old faithful "bankruptcy" in order to escape their obligations doesn't deserve a second chance from the same investor. OTOH, someone who finds a way to do the right thing, not matter how difficult, probably moves right to the top of that investor's list.
- true_religion 15y agoThere's no escape from obligations. If your company goes bankrupt without cash to pay off its obligations... its simply impossible to fulfill them. You are essentially saying as a hard-and-fast rule: do not invest in people who ran companies that declared bankruptcy, even once. I do not thing that kind of absolutist stigma should be associated with bankruptcy.
- tptacek 15y agoBKs happen and are factored into the price for a lot of business-to-business services. But no, I wouldn't invest in anyone who stiffed their employees. Ed is exactly right about that. And you wouldn't want to anyways. The kind of person who keeps employees on staff after they stop being certain they can make the next payroll isn't a good investment anyways.
- tluyben2 15y agoI see your point, but you have a lot of real-life experience? In Europe bankruptcy is a much bigger stigma than it is in the US; it haunts you forever and it's noted as one of the biggest reasons EU startups are less gutsy than US ones; if you go broke, you are screwed for life here. But it goes very very fast; I know a few product companies at least that went from going well to complete misery in a few months. Those are trains going to the wall with necessary burn rates of $1M+ / month; what I mean by that is, the only way to have a chance at survival is actually servicing the few clients (we're talking big contracts) you have left and during that trying to reinvent your business. This is a win or lose fight; sometimes you win, but if you lose, you have a good chance to be millions in debt in no time. We are still talking startups here, so no $15M war chest in the bank. Probably some of that money was investor or bank money as well. Other reasons can include a business partner screwing you or just both events at the same time :) For the same token I have seen companies get out of this predicament and they are doing extremely well now. So should they have thought; 'I'm not taking the risk, i'm paying everyone and closing the doors'? There was no in-between here; it's all or nothing in these cases. Sure you can say the growth rate was too high; doesn't that go for most invested startup companies in SV? I'm not sure it's as clear cut as you make it out to be especially if you make good on your employees with your next venture; i've seen cases were this was actually better for the employees as well. I feel that stiffing your employees is deliberately going for BK to not have to pay wages etc; standing with your arms up high, he yeah sucks, but we're BK and fuck you very much for your support! At least here that's an official crime and you will pay the price if the curator can prove you 'went for bankruptcy' for reasons of not paying employees and other (notably tax) bills. But I can see enough reasons where this can happen outside your control as well.