3 ms·
I believe that the assertion of absolute artistic merit is more dangerous than nihilistic relativism. A critic can be relativist and still be informative. Thei
by jfengel 5y ago
I believe that the assertion of absolute artistic merit is more dangerous than nihilistic relativism.
A critic can be relativist and still be informative. Their goal is not to assign a score to the art, but to communicate about it in an informed, meaningful way. Even if you have a completely different set of values from the critic, you can still appreciate criticism that informs you of what they saw and what it meant to them.
Roger Ebert famously hated having to give stars to films, because he was afraid you'd be misled. He could give a move five stars for being a very good slasher film, or action movie, or anything else in a genre he might dislike. Film critics see that aspect in spades, since they have often seen so many movies that even a "good" example will bore them simply because they've seen it all before. But that just gives them a reputation for only being interested in the obscure and outrageous, which appeal only because they're at least different.
A good critic can communicate what they see, without having to put an absolute judgment on it, because their judgment is unimportant to your decision to go view that piece of art. What you want is a preview of what that piece might mean to you, a thing established by your relationship to the critic.
Some critics write for the audience of people who may go see a piece, and others write for posterity -- the first draft of art history. Either is fine, though they're different modes.
This is a postmodernist view of what criticism means, and my point is to show that it doesn't have to be nihilistic. Art still has meaning to you, or not. But the art critic's job isn't to rank it, but to talk about that meaning -- and there's a lot to say. A nihilist just wouldn't say anything at all.