18 ms·
>but was told that Acer locks the BIOS on all computers shipped through Amazon in order to "protect" customers from changing things that might break the compute
by duxup 5y ago
>but was told that Acer locks the BIOS on all computers shipped through Amazon in order to "protect" customers from changing things that might break the computer if they don't know what they're doing.
That doesn't make any sense. Why would you lock it because it was sold through Amazon?
Is it accessible if you buy it direct from Acer?
Sounds like a customer support person just made up a reason.
- derefr 5y agoPerhaps it’s a workaround for Amazon’s commingled-stock problem. Third party can’t override Secure Boot to install a root kit and then return the laptop in a way that ends up with it commingled with “new” stock, if third parties can’t write to CMOS memory in the first place. (Of course, they could still install a “hard mod” root kit by e.g. reflashing the BIOS through its JTAG pins, or just desoldering it and soldering on something else. But that requires a much higher tier of resources, one that also enables other classes of attacks that don’t involve putting the stock back into the first-party warehouse.)
- adriancr 5y agojust wondering if its legal to sell returned products as new. I thought they were sold as refurbished/second chance with a discount.
- cortesoft 5y agoEven if it is illegal, lots of sellers on Amazon break the law... and since they co-mingle inventory from different sellers, one bad seller trying to pass off returns as new could contaminate every seller's products.
- fomine3 5y agoThis looks plausible. Also swap and return fraud can be blocked by this restriction.
- MattGaiser 5y agoAmazon has a large problem with fraudulent parts and co-mingled stock and customers returning swapped parts and not checking. Could be protection against that?
- cjohansson 5y agoSounds plausible, I'm voting for that explanation. Would be easier if Amazon was transparent about the real reason instead of giving a PR reason
- cbsmith 5y agoIn fairness, this is not Amazon support.
- MattGaiser 5y agoAnd Acer can't realistically say that Amazon is full of crooks/Amazon can't manage stuff.
- LordDragonfang 5y agoWhy not? If Amazon is facilitating fraud and computer crime by cutting corners on stock management, they should be called out for it by the companies impacted by it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- slver 5y ago> Sounds like a customer support person just made up a reason. This happens a lot, I find. People just hate having no answer for you. So they make up one.
- duxup 5y agoAgreed, customer service folks feel like they need to give an answer (totally understandable) and ... customer service isn't given many tools so they just make do with what they think might be true.
- wccrawford 5y agoHaving worked tech support, I can provide an alternative explanation: Customers hate not having a reason, and many techs will simply make one up rather than be yelled at again for not knowing.
- slver 5y agoWhat customers hate is tier 1 support acting as a brick wall between them and the people with the solution to their problem. Or at least that's how they perceive it. While I don't shout at tech support, as I know what the script is, you better believe my blood is quietly boiling as I'm rebooting various devices that have nothing to do with the issue on their instruction, just so I can get to an appointment with technicians to fix my real issue. Same thing occurs with GP doctors, and basically every other system in tiers, where it inevitably organizes to basically stall you, so people don't overload the higher tiers.
- wccrawford 5y agoThat's a different issue, though. We have problems that literally nobody knew the reason for, and they required formatting the hard drive and reinstalling Windows to fix. They did eventually figure things out, but it was over a year later, IIRC. In the mean time, the techs would get yelled at for not knowing what was happening. I wasn't surprised when they invented reasons... And they may even have believed them. As for the rebooting... I've seen too many weird things to deny them the reboots. And a few times it has actually fixed my problem, even though I believed it impossible. (And had the same happen to customers I was supporting.) So I know it's frustrating, but it's necessary in a surprising number of cases. Also, techs were often the worst customers. They thought they knew everything, even if it was just Dunning-Kruger. Forcing them to reboot was painful, but actually worked more often than non-techs because the non-techs would blindly try things like that after having been told it once in the past. There were plenty of times I fell back on the "I can't send this up until you reboot it" because I knew there was a good chance the reboot would actually work if the customer tried to avoid it.
- nrjames 5y agoThere are a lot of YouTube videos of people going into the BIOS on this same laptop, but acquired elsewhere. From what I can tell, it’s only the Amazon ones that have the BIOS locked.