7 ms·
The First Amendment begins "Congress shall make no law" (the Fourteenth Amendment brings in incorporation, so "Congress" should be read any US governmental auth
by jcranmer 5y ago
The First Amendment begins "Congress shall make no law" (the Fourteenth Amendment brings in incorporation, so "Congress" should be read any US governmental authority). By definition, no private actor (at least, no one not acting under color of law) is capable of violating your First Amendment rights.
While I understand that people try to frame this as protecting First Amendment rights, this is actually very literally the government requiring the companies to publish certain kinds of speech. There is a provision in the law that would require any covered social media provider to carry all posts from any declared candidate. Turns out, though, there's a handy SCOTUS case that says that requiring a newspaper to publish replies from elected officials is unconstitutional abrogation of the newspaper's free speech.
Just as the First Amendment protects the freedom of speech, it also protects the freedom from compelled speech.