4 ms·
To me, this doesn't seem like a tricky moral question at all. Investors are always supposed to be paid out last in bankruptcy proceedings, after whoever a comp
by crazygringo 5y ago
To me, this doesn't seem like a tricky moral question at all.
Investors are always supposed to be paid out last in bankruptcy proceedings, after whoever a company owes debt to. That's the "risk" part of being an investor. It's part of law. Everyone knows this up front, and the likelihood of it is built into stock prices.
There's zero analogy to leasing an apartment, where a tenant isn't expected to take on risk of the building collapsing -- that's handled by government-mandated inspections, insurance, etc etc.
And one would reasonably expect penalties and fines to be treated similarly to debt. How are they not a debt to the government? They should get paid off, and investors are left with whatever remains, if anything remains.
It can be trickier to apportion losses between people owed debt, or between investors owed in Madoff's case. But paying off debt should always come before paying off investors, full stop.
However, I'm genuinely confused as to why, in this case, SEC fines didn't get precedence in bankruptcy. Why on earth did lawmakers decide something else?
- AlbertCory 5y agoYou have some good points there, and IANAL although I've sure spent enough time with lawyers. SEC fines possibly should be the same seniority as the guy who sold them desks. I'd be interested to hear the rationale. On the other hand, are you considering "investors" in a fund that has a fiduciary duty to them on the same level as common stock holders in a cement company? It seems to me they are different.