3 ms·
This was a case that deserved a charitable reading. She was attempting to co-opt a slur that had been used against her. Unfortunately, co-opting slurs is hard.
by jfengel 5y ago
This was a case that deserved a charitable reading. She was attempting to co-opt a slur that had been used against her.
Unfortunately, co-opting slurs is hard. You'll get push back. It was the headline, and many people don't read past headlines. She wasn't normalizing hate speech, but she was reflecting hate speech, very much in public.
It's easy to call that a mistake in retrospect, and easy to say that as somebody who wasn't prepared for the consequences she should have shied away from it. That puts the blame on her and misses the bigger picture, that almost anybody can get caught up in forces far beyond their expectation or ability to handle that.
I don't know how to fix that. There's not much advice I can offer. I wish I could offer her some comfort, but probably the best thing I can do is leave her alone and hope that she can recover.
- zozbot234 5y ago> She wasn't normalizing hate speech, but she was reflecting hate speech, very much in public. Even if that was the case (and do note that the claim that the "attack helicopter" phrase is hate speech is by no means uncontroversial), how does this excuse the Twitter trolls who hurled far greater amounts of hate speech at her? Is this the sort of moral code that the "woke" would want to universalize on our society in their inerrant pursuit of perfect social justice - lex talionis on super steroids? Come on, even on its most charitable reading this makes absolutely zero sense.
- Wowfunhappy 5y ago> She was attempting to co-opt a slur that had been used against her. Actually, I'm pretty sure she used the slur as her writing prompt, which is far more interesting! Particularly as it generated a genuinely good story!
- jfengel 5y agoThat's a more accurate description of what happened, yes. It's more like satire than like co-option, but has some similar social dynamics.