7 ms·
I honestly don't understand why tech workers want unions. We're extremely well compensated and are dictating changes like forever WFH. We have generous vacatio
by echelon 5y ago
I honestly don't understand why tech workers want unions.
We're extremely well compensated and are dictating changes like forever WFH. We have generous vacation, perks, 401k contribution, ...
I want to get promoted because I work hard, not because of seniority. I want to be able to switch jobs or positions and not have to start at the bottom of the ladder.
Why would we want this?
Edit:
Unions will put pressure on the United States' ability to compete with Europe and other nations. Labor will be less flexible, and it's likely that top talent will be paid much less. Costs, however, will increase and the entire US tech industry will suffer.
We'll switch from nimble meritocracy to a regulated and calcified follower. The rest of the world will catch up. I don't get how that's good for the US.
Also, seeing all of the Europeans in here commenting about an American issue is odd.
- ttmb 5y agoIf you read the article, > Poché, [...] lives in Manhattan [...] earning just under $50,000 a year. That doesn't seem like "extremely well compensated"
- TheFreim 5y agoDepends on working conditions and if they're required to work in high cost area or not.
- collegecamp293 5y agoShe works as a "Campaigner" according to LinkedIn and is 23. What is the median salary for 23 year olds in Manhattan? EDIT: I googled "median salary" in Manhattan (no age qualifier) and you guessed it...it's $50,000
- dehrmann 5y agoI'll also add that as a "campaigner" working for someone like change.org, you can expect to make less because lots of people want to work in the these activist roles. It's similar to how game developers are paid less than b2b saas developers.
- Vaslo 5y agoAlways seems a shock to HN when the jobs that everyone wants that don’t require a very technical education tend to be on the low end. Well at least for the campaigner role.
- lasagnaphil 5y agoThe median salary of $50000 still seems a bit low to me considering how real estate must be pretty expensive in Manhattan. An okay-ish 1-bedroom apartment seems to be around at $2000 a month, which amounts to almost half of your salary (and I haven't really delved into the living costs of that area!)
- olah_1 5y agoI can confirm that this is a common salary for someone just out of college, even in NYC yes. She may work in Manhattan but she doesn't need to live there. Many young people have roomies in Brooklyn. It's what you sign up for when you choose to live in NYC.
- phreeza 5y agoAll those downsides you mention are not automatic consequences of having a union. Look at union jobs in Europe for a better example of how things can work out. All the nice perks you mention are completely at the discretion of your employer. Ask yourself this: Why would you voluntarily forgo leverage to be gained on your employer?
- collegecamp293 5y agoAverage pay for union jobs in Europe is far less than $50,000
- toomuchtodo 5y agoAnd yet quality of life is much higher.
- klyrs 5y agoThat's one side of the equation; what's the cost of living?
- missedthecue 5y agoAccording to the OECD, Americans have more disposable after adjusting for government transfers for things like healthcare, education, and childcare. And it's not even close. https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-disposable-income.htm https://data.oecd.org/hha/household-disposable-income.htm
- beaconstudios 5y agoMost unions in Europe are for blue collar work. In the UK (anecdotally) I've seen a lot more developers form cooperatives than unions, and even the cooperatives are fairly rare.
- duxup 5y ago>Why would you voluntarily forgo leverage to be gained on your employer? Because in this case it isn't in Europe? I like the European tradition a lot more than the frequent outcomes with US unions. I've seen US unions where what the original poster describes is totally accurate.
- Nicksil 5y ago>We're extremely well compensated and are dictating changes like forever WFH. We have generous vacation, perks, 401k contribution, ... You presume this sort of compensation is enjoyed throughout our industry. It isn't.
- Vaslo 5y agoThat’s the beauty of the industry though. If you don’t like your work or don’t think you are compensated enough, you are free to apply and work at any number of other tech companies around the world.
- edoceo 5y agoUnions don't block those features you want. All Labor benefits from group power against Capital. Your job today benefits from Union efforts in decades past.
- duxup 5y ago>Unions don't block those features you want. They can in some cases do, particularly in the US. It's still a possibility.
- echelon 5y agoMy job has nothing to do with unions of the past. edit: Fair points. I still believe that modern labor is a highly dynamical system. Many workers do need additional support and benefits, but our corner of the world is one of the best compensated and least regulated. Solutions for getting low-paid workers better equity shouldn't be used as a hammer -- workers earning six to seven figures do not need unions. Unions in tech will put downward pressure on our mobility, competitiveness, and compensation.
- Nicksil 5y ago>My job has nothing to do with unions of the past. But you enjoy many of the benefits past union members fought and died for.
- Vaslo 5y agoAnd we also have negative outcomes such as discounting worker education and experience (seniority should NEVER be valued over talent), restriction of work to narrow definitions leading to inefficiencies, the fact that the increased cost and decreased deficiencies hurt the product’s customers, and the list goes on and on. We owe a debt to those who worked to get us simple humane things like taking children out of coalmines and getting benefits for working beyond 40 hours per week. Those days are gone. Now they fight to keep people who get drunk on the job or try to tell our factories that some people should stand around and do nothing because asking them to help move some parts from one room to another isn’t in their narrowly defined job description.
- throw_m239339 5y ago> I honestly don't understand why tech workers want unions. Read Shopify's CEO speech about being a team and not a "family". Also read Coinbase CEO. These "tech unions" are PACS, not your traditional worker unions.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoBecause those who are marginalized are more important to me than those doing exceptional well, even if I’m doing exceptional well. I care little about promotions or status, nor does my job mean much to me other than income (it’s what I do with a small part of my life, not who I am), so I’m optimizing for different metrics than others. I have done well enough for a lifetime, and I’d rather spend my energy pulling the rest of folks up (both in comp and quality of life). Don’t wealthy people spend their time on philanthropy when they’re done hustling? I say, “why wait?” and do what you can where you are with what you have. Compensation has diminishing utility, while I have found compassionate efforts do not. YMMV. (Onward to legally mandated PTO, fewer day work weeks, wfh, and stronger labor rights for everyone; society grows great when old people plant trees whose shade they know they shall never sit in) Edit reply to your edit: Top talent is a small minority. You’re basically asking the majority “Why do you want better for all of yourselves at the detriment to the very few amongst us capturing a majority of the gains?”
- dharmab 5y agoTech workers are not evenly compensated. If you work in FAANG or most enterprises, you're probably happy. Not if you work in gamedev, or many non-software oriented companies.
- ironmagma 5y agoWhen you say “we,” you are speaking from your perspective. The reason there are such high earners is that there are also low earners.
- chomp 5y agoUnions are nothing more than a way to negotiate with capital as a single entity. There's more to negotiating as a union than wringing more bennies out of the employer. Things like "hey is sustained 60 hours a week really acceptable" "why do I have to put work email on my phone and be responsive 24/7" and "it's been 7 years boss and we haven't gotten new workstations" are all things that are up for bargaining. It's about negotiating things as a group that would get you laughed at or demoted if you were to do it by yourself. Unions do not preclude promotions from merit. Unions do not preclude hiring people at the middle of the pay scale. Don't construct a straw man of the worst things you can think of, and package them up as the average union, because it isn't.
- pydry 5y agoThey can also lobby on moral grounds - e.g. cracking down on dark patterns, against doing business with abusive regimes or domestic concentration camp operators.
- cratermoon 5y agoAlso work against stack ranking, hire-to-fire, the ridiculous leetcode obsession, and other toxic workplace practices endemic to the industry.
- endtime 5y ago> Things like "hey is sustained 60 hours a week really acceptable" "why do I have to put work email on my phone and be responsive 24/7" and "it's been 7 years boss and we haven't gotten new workstations" are all things that are up for bargaining. Do SWEs in the US actually have any of these problems? Maybe I'm spoiled by my FAANG job but I find it hard to imagine these kinds of work conditions even at a non-FAANG tech company.
- tmp_anon_22 5y agoThat's the thing, you have to fight these things even when they're not happening because over time they will happen. Everyone was surprised when Google and Apple came back hard against remote working but that's just what big businesses do. As software is increasingly commoditized over the next 5 decades we'll see a huge degradation in employee compensation even as profits for these companies continue to grow.
- Apocryphon 5y ago> We're extremely well compensated and are dictating changes like forever WFH. We have generous vacation, perks, 401k contribution, ... Doctors, psychiatrists, and lawyers have professional associations. Professional athletes and Hollywood actors (as well as other film industry workers) are also unionized.
- slavik81 5y agoProfessional associations are from different from unions. The stated reason for the existence of a professional association is the protection of the public. Unions, on the other hand, exist for the benefit of their members.
- Vaslo 5y agoI know several lawyers who barely have two nickels to rub together. If that’s what a professional association gets me, I’ll pass.
- Apocryphon 5y agoThere's a glut of lawyers, despite all of the gatekeeping and credentialing in that industry. Don't think you can blame it on the ABA for that. Not sure if they're the ones behind exorbitant law school tuitions either. Not to mention, that's only one profession out of several. What has the IEEE done against you lately?
- goodpoint 5y agoUnions do much more than negotiating salaries. The whole software industry could benefit from: - Setting quality standards. Ensuring people are properly trained and so on. E.g. Preventing Boeing from offshoring development of the MCAS to engineers paid $9 an hour. - Setting ethical standards. E.g. Preventing car pollution "defeat device". Providing legal support for whistleblowers. - Fighting ageism. It's provably widespread in SV. - Fighting the no-poaching agreements. Many FAANGs were found to be colluding. - Sighing exploitative immigration rules like the H1B "leash" that creates a class of underpaid workers. > We'll switch from nimble meritocracy to a regulated and calcified follower This is an absurd claim. Any human organization can be calcified or stay nimble. Unions are not different.
- sokoloff 5y ago> Setting ethical standards. E.g. Preventing car pollution "defeat device" Are VW engineers not part of a union/workers' council? If they are, um...
- Nicksil 5y agoum... what? Finish your thought.
- sokoloff 5y agoOK, since you asked: Why did their membership in a union not preclude this outcome, given that one of the purported benefits of unions is to prevent such outcomes?
- goodpoint 5y agoThis is like asking "why did greenpeace not preclude climate change". Because that behavior is widespread across the whole industry, across many countries and across 4/5 decades: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defeat_device https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defeat_device https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_emissions_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_emissions_scandal Unions, just like any other non-governative organization, are just as powerful as people support them.
- LatteLazy 5y agoBroadly I agree with you but these aren't really tech workers, they sound more like soft sales to me...