6 ms·
I'm a fan of free speech, but defamation is one of the limits I agree with. The UK has a stricter framework than the US, but I think these cases should happen
by echelon 5y ago
I'm a fan of free speech, but defamation is one of the limits I agree with.
The UK has a stricter framework than the US, but I think these cases should happen in the US too.
It's good to see precedent being established for prosecuting those that abuse social media for evil.
I'm interested in who the guilty party is in this case. They can afford a six figure penalty and want to remain anonymous.
- th0ma5 5y agoDoes this opinion have anything to do with the scandals one might be able to find with a simple google search of your username?
- duxup 5y agoIt may be just the type of stories I happen to see. But I feel like I run into more cases where UK defamation laws have some absurd outcomes ... and I'm not sure the result is that there's less defamation in the UK.
- wutbrodo 5y agoThere's no question that the UK's speech laws are abusive, especially to American sensibilities. You can find stories of people being arrested for calling a police horse "gay", or saying "woof" to a police dog, or the guy who taught his girlfriend's dog to respond to Seig Heil to troll her, or the 19 y/o who quoted a Snoop Dogg lyric on her Instagram page, or the guy sent to _jail_ for leaving anti-religion cartoons in an airport restroom. These cases are among the ridiculous fringe, so a bunch of them were overturned or resulting solely in fines, but they're the tip of the iceberg of the more mundane gov't suppression of speech and accompanying chilling effects that the UK has decided it wants. Though that doesn't imply that defamation has no place in speech laws, nor that the case in question was necessarily abusive.
- Marazan 5y agoWith regards to the Nazi dog your facts are wrong. He taught the dog to respond to the phrase "Do you wanna gas the Jews"
- wutbrodo 5y ago> With regards to the Nazi dog your facts are wrong. He taught the dog to respond to the phrase "Do you wanna gas the Jews" No, your facts are wrong. He taught the dog to perform a nazi salute upon hearing the command Seig Heil, _and_ to bark upon hearing "gas the jews". The description of his video is only a couple of sentences long on Wikipedia.
- rovolo 5y agoI don't think you're giving a great summary of these stories. The first two are related to personal defamation: * Police horse and dog: people could be arrested for "threatening, abusive or insulting" speech in public at the time. The police, being wankers, overused their discretion on "insulting" speech and so the law was changed in 2013 to remove "insulting" as a criterion. https://newsfeed.time.com/2013/01/16/you-may-now-call-a-police-horse-gay-in-the-u-k/ https://newsfeed.time.com/2013/01/16/you-may-now-call-a-poli... The rest fall under hate speech: * Seig Heil dog: fined £800 for hate speech for posting a video of the dog to YouTube. He said "gas the Jews" to the dog 23 times. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/dog-nazi-salute-sentence-mark-meechan-video-pug-sieg-heil/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/dog-nazi-salute-sentence-mark-m... * 19 y/o Snoop Dogg lyric: 8 week curfew, fined £600. She added "kill a snitch n** and rob a rich n**" to her Instagram bio. https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/woman-who-posted-rap-lyrics-14543694 https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/woman-wh... * The guy repeatedly left the cartoons in airport _prayer-rooms_. "Other [images] linked Muslims to attacks on airports." 6 month suspended prison sentence (not sure about the length of the pre-trial detention), fined £250, 100hrs unpaid work (community service?). http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/merseyside/8549613.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/merseyside/854961... I don't necessarily agree with the criminalization, but these 3 instances were all people doing shitty things I don't think they should have done. Downplaying the parts people actually got angry about makes it seem like you're complaining about the people getting angry about the actions rather than the trials and punishments.
- mcguire 5y agoThanks for the details! Any news on Simon Singh and the British Chiropractic Association or the Church of Scientology?
- rovolo 5y agoThis is what I found with a quick search. * Simon Singh & BCA: appeals court changed Singh's "statement of fact" to "fair comment" (opinion) in 2010. The BCA then withdrew the libel lawsuit. The "Libel Reform Campaign" used this case to push for a 2013 act which modified libel laws. * I don't know which Scientology libel suit you're asking about. The most recent news item I could find was a 2015 chilling effect where a local broadcaster and publisher rethought showing/printing "Going Clear" because Northern Ireland wasn't covered by the 2013 libel law. The latest actual libel suit I could find was a 6 year libel case where: (ex-Scientologist) Bonnie Woods started a phoneline for other dissenters, the Scientologists printed leaflets calling her a "hate campaigner" and distributed them in Hood's neighborhood, Hood sued, the Scientologists counter-sued, Hood eventually won a settlement. https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2015/03/21/394273902/on-libel-and-the-law-u-s-and-u-k-go-separate-ways https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2015/03/21/394273902/... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology_in_the_United_King...
- jaywalk 5y agoI would call this an absurd outcome. This guy is a public figure, and it doesn't seem like anything bad actually happened to him as a result of the trolling. So how in the hell is a six-figure payout justified?
- s_dev 5y agoIreland like the UK has strong defamation laws. I suspect it plays a part in concealing political corruption rather protecting an individuals right to a reputation as pointed out by EU officials a couple of times.
- benrbray 5y agoI don't have a horse in this race, but playing devil's advocate: USA doesn't have strong defamation laws, and yet we still have well-concealed corruption.
- jldugger 5y ago> well-concealed Are you sure about that? It seems pretty out in the open.
- benrbray 5y agoWe have plenty of both kinds :). "Truth" being a valid defense against defamation laws protects some whistleblowers, but for the big stuff we play the "national security" card.
- s_dev 5y agoI don't think the defamation laws are the only approach to concealing corruption -- just one way thats popular in the UK & Ireland.
- deleted 5y ago
- AlexandrB 5y agoDefamation is a great way for those with money to silence dissent and avoid any consequences. Say our product sucks? Defamation. Claim you were sexually assaulted? Defamation. Even if what you said is true, would you be willing to spend the money to go to court and try to fight a defamation lawsuit?
- NoboruWataya 5y agoI'm not sure that's true - or rather, I think it's exaggerated. First, truth is generally a defence to defamation, and costs follow the cause in the UK so a losing party would generally be required to pay both parties' costs. Now, defamation suits can still be costly and painful even if you are in the right, so they do surely have some chilling effect. But the risk and likely cost of trying to silence legitimate criticisms with frivolous defamation lawsuits is quite high. Second, defamation suits are public, and often make for juicy headlines. If you really want to silence your critics, dragging them into a public forum to repeat their claims in front of a load of reporters is probably not the best way to do it.
- mcguire 5y agoThat has partially changed in the last 10 years. https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2015/03/21/394273902/on-libel-and-the-law-u-s-and-u-k-go-separate-ways https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2015/03/21/394273902/...
- 45ure 5y ago>Defamation is a great way for those with money to silence dissent and avoid any consequences. Your comment seems to fit the profile of Brewdog, a UK based 'craft brewery'. They are known for deliberately courting controversy. The egregious examples include frivolous claims on trademarks, misogyny, bullying, harassment, amongst toe-curling and churlish behaviour, when they appeared on a BBC programme Who's The Boss. The latest 'Gold Can' escapade is another deceptive marketing campaign, which is their raison d'être. The strategy works, as it is doing them no harm and the growth is phenomenal. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/jun/10/brewdog-punk-brewery-beer-scottish-brewer-controversy https://www.theguardian.com/business/2021/jun/10/brewdog-pun... https://www.thedrinksbusiness.com/2016/03/brewdog-boss-regrets-disaster-tv-appearance/ https://www.thedrinksbusiness.com/2016/03/brewdog-boss-regre... https://www.bbc.com/news/business-57650685 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-57650685
- 34679 5y ago>It's good to see precedent being established for prosecuting those that abuse social media for evil. It's also good to see precedents established for people trying to abuse the system: "Judge tosses frivolous lawsuit by heiress Sulome Anderson seeking to destroy The Grayzone" https://thegrayzone.com/2021/06/29/lawsuit-sulome-anderson-hezbollah/ https://thegrayzone.com/2021/06/29/lawsuit-sulome-anderson-h...
- akersten 5y agoNo, the US gets this right, and this case would be thrown out promptly were it in American jurisdiction (well, presumably - I don't know the extent of the "trolling" since the article is scant on detail, but I assume it's nothing over-the-top or they would have brought it to light to support their case). There's a much higher bar to establish defamation against Public Figures in the US -- as there should be. They are famous, they can deal with and expect to be trolled. That's part of the deal of being famous - you have haters. I don't think anyone should have to pay out because they trolled a famous person on Twitter.
- Barrin92 5y agoI'm not really sure why being famous is supposed to diminish your rights in regards to defamation, or really in regards to anything. If someone spreads falsehoods against another person in a way that damages their reputation they ought to have legal means at their disposal to set that straight. I don't really see why the US gets this right at all, it's just part of Americas culture where lies and truth are treated as equal and as a result integrity has completely vanished from public discourse. Very visible in how all politicians are treated as 'being the same', which is the logical consequence of this atmosphere of defamation which trolls abuse with impunity. If you can lie without repercussion about everyone, the public cannot distinguish reality from fiction.
- mcguire 5y agohttps://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/defamation https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/defamation For defamation, you need four things: a false statement of fact made to a third party causing actual harm, that demonstrates at least negligence. For public figures, the "at least negligence" rises to "actual malice"; I believe the intention is to prevent public figures from abusing defamation suits. Note that "lying", saying something that you know to be false or with "reckless disregard" for whether it is false, is pretty much the definition of "actual malice" in this case. You cannot lie without repercussion.
- dangerface 5y ago> They are famous, they can deal with and expect to be trolled. Citation needed I don't think any one on youtube or twitch has the resources or interest in dealing with lies being spread about them. I can't think of any legitimate reason the law should protect liars at the expense of every one else. I can't think of any legitimate reason that popular people should be subject to a different set of laws from the rest of us, that seems deeply biased and un fair.
- dangerface 5y agoAbsolutely free speech doesn't mean you are free to use your speech to attack people and spread lies.
- krapp 5y ago>Absolutely free speech doesn't mean you are free to use your speech to attack people and spread lies. Yes it does, that's exactly what it means. People disagree on what "free speech" means, on what limits can legitimately be placed on that freedom and by whom, but the implications of "absolutely free" speech are unambiguous.
- walshemj 5y agoGo in the wrong pub in NI and shout up the RA (PIRA) /UDA and see what happens.
- meowface 5y agoI think it just has to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. If someone anonymously tweets something knowingly false along the lines of "[X] is a rapist/pedophile and I have proof", I agree you should be able to sue that person. A false, defamatory accusation like that can easily ruin your career and life. But I can imagine plenty of things that someone could argue are defamatory which fall into a much grayer area where I believe court involvement isn't warranted. I think this debate will just run in circles until all of the tweets in question are presented.
- xxpor 5y agoThat is an example that US defamation law would cover as well. For public figures, normally you have to demonstrate actual malice to win a defamation case. But there are certain things that are defamation per se, in other words are always considered defamation unless they're true. The list differs per state, but things like calling someone a pedophile is always on it. Fun fact: saying someone was gay used to be considered defamation per se.
- meowface 5y agoRight. Maybe I'm biased because I'm American, but I think the US defamation laws seem pretty reasonable. I'm curious to see the tweets so I can see how I feel about the UK's laws and enforcement.
- logicalmonster 5y agoIt's hard to judge this specific case from the article because it's limited in its details of what actual criticism about this person was expressed. But to me, the problem inherent in defamation (as well as "fake news") isn't that people are able to utter false statements. The real issue is that many people are conditioned to believe that whatever they see or hear is true. Somebody believing something negative is the only thing that might cause harm to another person. Why do people believe that whatever they read or hear is true? I believe it's because we have active defamation/slander laws, "fact checkers", and other things designed to combat false information. Their very existence and strength is what keeps people conditioned to believe that everything they see is true. And the stronger they get, the stronger that people believe that everything they read is true. It's a feedback loop that worsens the problem it's supposed to solve. Paradoxically, things like strong defamation laws may worsen the real problem they're ostensibly designed to solve. I strongly believe that the approach that should be taken with things like defamation isn't harsher and harsher punishment, it should be telling everybody that nothing you read online is true and having the weakest possible defamation laws (or even no laws in this regard) to get people to understand that nothing that they see or read should be considered true until they verify it. A society that understands that no facts should be considered true until they verify it would be immune from false information.