6 ms·
I read the original WSJ. I guess the tricky moral question is: were the investors partially culpable for the crime, or blameless victims? You can say "they shou
by AlbertCory 5y ago
I read the original WSJ. I guess the tricky moral question is: were the investors partially culpable for the crime, or blameless victims? You can say "they should have been more diligent" but are you equally willing to apply that standard to ALL fraud victims? Example:
You moved into an unsafe apartment building that collapsed snd killed you -- "too bad, you should have checked it out better! The signs were there."
Bernie Madoff ran a Ponzi scheme and paid early investors with the funds of later ones. The early people who benefited from the fraud were forced to disgorge their "investment returns" and some of that money was returned to the later ones. So was that "justice?" Should the whistleblower have gotten some of that?
Not easy questions. Don't be too quick to take sides.
- baybal2 5y agoThe legal system should not protect ponzi schemes investors, or just any investors. Somebody's lack of commercial sense, and financial stupidity should not be rewarded with such "insurance" by the public. American ultralitigious banker/investor culture effectively rewards people going completely casino with their, or, more often, somebody's else money.
- lallysingh 5y agoThe system protects investors who were lied to. Yes that includes lies that are a bit obvious, but the result is a very, very healthy investment economy in the US. Investing is safer from flat-out fraud in the US, and that makes for more investment.
- AlbertCory 5y agoCorrect. You don't want to reward the people who are exceptionally good liars, like Madoff: the ones who can con those who normally can't be conned. There are actually people who believe a message that their Social Security number has been compromised, and they have to pay money to avoid going to prison. The stupid deserve fraud protection, too.
- aeturnum 5y ago> the result is a very, very healthy investment economy in the US. There were some recent examples of this system creating perverse incentives for US investments that are worth considering. For instance, the repackaging of mortgage-backed securities in the 2007 financial crisis took advantage of multiple transfers to place all risks on consumers and allow brokers to evade nearly all risk. I think that we need to think very carefully about what risks we protect against (and how) to avoid situations where middle-men capture down-side protections as alpha and gain an incentive to seek out investments that are priced lower because they will often fail. A model that imagines an investment market where the only two parties are the investment originator and the final owner are too simplistic now.
- AlbertCory 5y agoAbsolutely. Privatizing the profit and socializing the risk is the wrong model.
- zucker42 5y agoProtecting investors from being lied to incentivizes investors to spend less resources on discerning whether representations made to them are true. "More investment" isn't a definite good if it leads to investment in the wrong places.
- mcguire 5y ago"Ponzi schemes investors" are technically known as victims.
- gowld 5y agoThis is the fundamental cost and benefit of the LLC -- investors get to profit from the risk assumed by counterparties. Never extend credit to an LLC unless you have a good risk model for default.
- matthewdgreen 5y agoIf we're going to have mechanisms like fines and penalties, and we're going to use those fines to support whistleblower reward programs, then we're going to have to resolve these questions. Because what we have now is a whistleblower reward program that does not work, at least in certain circumstances.
- crazygringo 5y agoTo me, this doesn't seem like a tricky moral question at all. Investors are always supposed to be paid out last in bankruptcy proceedings, after whoever a company owes debt to. That's the "risk" part of being an investor. It's part of law. Everyone knows this up front, and the likelihood of it is built into stock prices. There's zero analogy to leasing an apartment, where a tenant isn't expected to take on risk of the building collapsing -- that's handled by government-mandated inspections, insurance, etc etc. And one would reasonably expect penalties and fines to be treated similarly to debt. How are they not a debt to the government? They should get paid off, and investors are left with whatever remains, if anything remains. It can be trickier to apportion losses between people owed debt, or between investors owed in Madoff's case. But paying off debt should always come before paying off investors, full stop. However, I'm genuinely confused as to why, in this case, SEC fines didn't get precedence in bankruptcy. Why on earth did lawmakers decide something else?
- AlbertCory 5y agoYou have some good points there, and IANAL although I've sure spent enough time with lawyers. SEC fines possibly should be the same seniority as the guy who sold them desks. I'd be interested to hear the rationale. On the other hand, are you considering "investors" in a fund that has a fiduciary duty to them on the same level as common stock holders in a cement company? It seems to me they are different.