6 ms·
Or... to look at it another way, when there isn't enough money left in a company, harmed investors are paid first, then whistleblowers/government fines. That
by londons_explore 5y ago
Or... to look at it another way, when there isn't enough money left in a company, harmed investors are paid first, then whistleblowers/government fines.
That seems right to me...
- sombremesa 5y agoIt's not right, because now it's in the whistleblowers' best interest to get in on the scam and enrich themselves instead of reporting anything, since the act of whistleblowing is equivalent to shooting yourself in the foot while biting the hand that's feeding you. I suppose it is right depending on who's side you're on.
- OGforces 5y agoIt’s not in the best interest of a whistleblower to get in on the scam. The trope of “incentives” is overblown. People don’t directly respond only to a single incentive. It’s in the best interest of the whistleblower to keep his head low instead of report.
- milesvp 5y agoI think you are in agreement with the parent post. There was an implied /s in the tone. Systemically it’s a huge problem to favor investors over whistleblowers and fines. You want incentives to be aligned wherever possible, and being able to declare bankruptcy in order to protect the very people benefiting from unscrupulous acts just leads to more unscrupulous behavior.
- sombremesa 5y ago> There was an implied /s in the tone. I strongly disagree with this, because the GP has used the term "harmed investors". I think it's a dangerous practice to go around claiming other people's posts are tongue in cheek. That's how we come to allow 'locker room talk'.
- milesvp 5y agoThe heavy use of ellipses is a common giveaway for sarcasm in casual writing in the US. But I agree, part of what makes "good" sarcasm is that it's easy to interpret as being either for or against something depending on the audience, and this leads to issues like "locker room talk", allowing some unfortunate ideas to persist because it appears people agree with them. I also think sarcasm should be used sparingly on this particular forum, it's important to try to limit the possibility of ambiguity in order to foster better discussions.
- mcguire 5y ago"...it's in the whistleblowers' best interest to get in on the scam and enrich themselves..." That has always been the case.
- mandmandam 5y agoIt seems right to you that investors in a company caught running a $1.4 billion scam should receive a billion dollars - while the whistleblower loses his career and gets nothing? ... Really? Like, do you know how big a billion :is:?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cobookman 5y agoThe investors ONLY saw a 28.5% loss (1B/1.4B). In the scheme of things it could have been way worse if the whistleblower didn't speak up. If they gave say 1% of the assets to the whistleblower (10 Million), it wouldn't have really changed the investor payout all that much. BUT it would encourage future whistleblowers. Especially when the whistleblower speaking up earlier prevent further losses to impacted investors.
- londons_explore 5y agoI wonder what the expected change in the loss to investors is compared to the delay in a whistleblower coming forward. I suspect a lot of companies which have illegally covered up losses have later managed to recoup losses to make investors whole again, and have never been discovered. In these cases, investors end up better off without a whistleblower.
- ivalm 5y agoI guess seems partially wrong to me. While I agree government should collect after aggrieved investors, I think whistleblowers should come first as they are the ones enabling fraud detection.
- irjustin 5y agoI think there's something to be said that investors who recouped funds should have a portion allocated to the whistleblower program if that's how investors got their money back. Seems more fair.
- 3pt14159 5y agoYou surely must be joking! Harmed investors are the ones that should have done the due diligence in the first place. That they got anything back at all was due to the diligence of the whistle blower. People should be rewarded for calling out white collar crime and the fees should extend to the people actually operating the fraud.
- jeltz 5y agoI am prerty sure he was sarcastic. Obviously investors should be last.
- bidirectional 5y agoWhy? It doesn't read as sarcastic to me -- investors are the ones being harmed by the scam. Obviously the current system needs to support whistleblowers more, but I don't get why one would make a sarcastic comment about helping the victims.
- gowld 5y agoInvestors got their compensationin advance -- their loses are limited to the amount invested, regardless of liability incurred. Thus additional compensation should be below the rights of creditors who performed work on their behalf. If it's the other way around, then you could go around investing in companies that never pay their bills, ripping off everyone you do business with.
- dantheman 5y agoThe investors were defrauded - that's why the SEC was investigating...
- fastball 5y agoThe investors weren't operating the fraud, they were being defrauded...
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoGovernment should collect before investors, otherwise you create a perverse incentive on the part of investors to ignore malfeasance.
- Spooky23 5y agoThe problem is the government made a policy decision to use whistleblowers as a tool to police malfeasance, rather than hire and pay civil servants to do the same. As implemented, the law takes away the financial incentive for whistleblowers to take action on the most egregious cases. If a fraudster being uncovered will put the offending entity out of business, there’s no incentive to risk getting blackballed.
- shadilay 5y agoAssuming an investor wants a maximum payout and that the % of money recovered decreases as the fraud perpetuates, the early recovery-whistleblower cut could be greater than a late recovery.