3 ms·
The United States has been fractious since the beginning. It degenerated into a Civil War that had been brewing since its inception. The Constitution was full o
by jfengel 5y ago
The United States has been fractious since the beginning. It degenerated into a Civil War that had been brewing since its inception. The Constitution was full of rules designed to grant extra power to those who went on to secede anyway.
Nor did the end of the war settle anything. The reconciliation project was quickly put down, and the losers of the war set about memorializing and lionizing their heroes. The violence continued, but quietly.
The next century is what we think of as that "American identity", where we were too busy making money and becoming the international superpower to wage large-scale violence on each other. That fractured after World War II, when the people who weren't benefitting from that demanded an end to discrimination.
That's been the story for the last half century, as the gradual success of marginalized groups gives that original urge to fracture America a new urge to express their grievance. And that grudge is so old that it's practically impossible to talk about. You can see it in this thread already. They see it as a personal and modern imposition, talking about great old days that simply did not exist -- not for everybody.
- zozbot234 5y ago> ... Nor did the end of the war settle anything. ... You can try to tell that story and it's not without merit, but the logical consequence of it is that reconciliation hadn't even been tried in a meaningful way until the 1980s, when Southern elites finally internalized the outcomes of the 1960s Civil Rights era and set out trying to build a new foundation for economic freedom and development, that could ultimately benefit the winners and losers of that conflict alike. We're still very early in that project, just like we're early in the project of reducing and ultimately ending discrimination of marginalized groups. These endeavors should ultimately be seen as complementary, not oppositional. But the divisive politics we're all too familiar with seems to have very little room for such a nuanced POV.
- jfengel 5y agoIt's getting off to a bumpy start. It corresponds to the start of the Southern Strategy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_strategy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_strategy Despite the consistency I was describing, the political map changed radically during that time. The electoral map today looks awfully reminiscent of 1860, but between then and now it was completely different. The Civil Rights era prompted a return to Civil War geographic lines, albeit with the parties flipped. Most prominently, a lot of Southern Democrats switched parties at exactly the time frame you mention, precisely to avoid being part of that reconciliation. There may ultimately be a reconciliation and a win-win scenario, but it's not going quietly. There's a lot of benefit to stoking those very old grievances.