3 ms·
The timbres of almost all (pleasant) physical instruments, including the human voice, make octaves and fifths (1/2 and 1/3 frequency ratios) important (and plea
by lmm 5y ago
The timbres of almost all (pleasant) physical instruments, including the human voice, make octaves and fifths (1/2 and 1/3 frequency ratios) important (and pleasant) intervals (the clarinet is a rare exception where the twelfth is the important interval, but even then that's an octave plus a fifth - music intervals use 1-based indexing which is definitely historical legacy).
The circle of fifths and equal-temperament tuning is a kludge, and there are alternatives (and you can go back to baroque times and hear pieces written for different tunings), but no approach is perfect; fundamentally 2^x will never equal 3^y so you have to compromise somewhere.
7-note scales are not the only one possible - a pentatonic scale produces pleasant sounds, as do the various medieval modes - but you can't go much finer without things sounding unpleasant (and eventually with microtone tuning you reach a point where people will hear beats instead of distinct tones). A 7-note scale also fits conveniently with the circle of fifths to allow you to have a single instrument that can play in multiple keys.
Fundamentally you do want to be able to write runs up and down the scale, so a notation of 7 points with sharps/flats is a lot more convenient than a notation of 12 points where a run would have seemingly-arbitrary gaps and off-scale notes look the same as on-scale notes.
If you're actually interested, I'd highly recommend doing some practical musicmaking and/or conventional academic study rather than trying to theorise everything from first principles yourself. After all, many of these principles were refined over centuries of trial and error, while the fundamental physical underpinnings were only discovered very recently.
- galaxyLogic 5y ago> with microtone tuning you reach a point where people will hear beats instead of distinct tones) That's a fantastic notion. Music consists of rhythm melody and harmony. Harmony is created by relations of frequencies. But Rhythm itself IS a frequency, and there can be several overlapping rhythms in a piece of music. Melodic steps are also ratios between frequencies, but pieces of melody also repeat in a piece of music. So its all about frequencies and frequency of changing the frequencies. Something like that. The simple point is that rhythm is a frequency. A note is a frequency.
- lmm 5y ago"Beats" is a specific term of art. It's not related to rhythm.
- pessimizer 5y agoIt's a term of art describing the regular rhythmic peaks when discordant notes are played together.
- kaoD 5y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beat_(acoustics) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beat_(acoustics)
- tsegratis 5y agoTrue. Much of the above article's analysis of scales applies equally well to an analysis of rhythm, and the circle-bead diagrams for scales he uses are still the best pictograph method ive seen to get a visual impression of a beat over a single bar -- bar a.k.a. scale
- janstice 5y agoAny time you feel like you have too much money and spare time, you should get into modular synths - I think you might really dig it.
- galaxyLogic 5y agoPrecisely what I was thinking of, how you can start with a low frequency oscillator and turn it up, until it becomes a note. Rhythm turns into note. Multiple rhythms turn into harmony.