3 ms·
FTA: “The new battery uses a tabless design that promises to be 35% smaller than conventional batteries, which promises to be cheaper, safer and more powerful.
by Someone 5y ago
FTA: “The new battery uses a tabless design that promises to be 35% smaller than conventional batteries, which promises to be cheaper, safer and more powerful.
According to Tesla, this means the battery offers five times more energy and six times more power, all of which comes together to offer 16% more range per kilowatt hour of juice.”
I don’t follow that math. All else being equal, 35% smaller means about 50% more range if they go for the same size battery. If it’s only 15%, they must make the battery smaller by about 25%.
That’s fine, but where does the “six times more power” come from. What do they compare that with?
Can’t be current cars, since range would then be six times as large, and they wouldn’t want to build such a car (better build a cheaper car with a bit less range, don’t want to compete with own more expensive models)
(It might work out mathematically if these new batteries were incredibly heavy, but the article says it’s lighter)
What do I miss?
- nickik 5y agoWhat you miss is that people throw out a bunch of number that use different base numbers and so on. The reality is very complex. This is a long video series attempting to explain everything from Battery Day: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLyvdbTy3v1d5luwdDGPFPab9WWPmMW_cJ https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLyvdbTy3v1d5luwdDGPFP... You can watch only the last video if you want a more simple overview.
- maximus-decimus 5y agoThe five times more energy dense and 6 times the power refers to the design explained on Tesla's Battery day. Seriously, they made a 2 hours presentation about it. Total nerd porn : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6T9xIeZTds https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6T9xIeZTds This really applies to the cells, not the battery itself, I think they just misunderstood. This is in comparison to the current design. They did that mostly by... making the cells bigger! I think the battery itself is 35% smaller because this removes the need for using tabs and the cell volume/surface area is greater. Also note that "six times the power" doesn't mean six times the range. Power is energy per unit of time so it really only tells you how fast you can use the energy in your battery (and I'm assuming how fast you can charge.)
- Someone 5y agoYeah, “six times the power” was a lapse of me. Intended to copy-paste the “five times the energy” part. The math still doesn’t hold up, making this article as good as content free for me. History so far tells that we can’t trust their projections on price and delivery date, not to mention full self driving. So, the content for me is “Tesla is working on a hatchback”.
- maximus-decimus 5y agoI think what you're missing is the big improvement comes from removing the tabs. This allows them to remove a ton of dead weight basically. But yeah the article is terrible. It's like they decided 9 months late to make an article about Battery Day.