3 ms·
>Why We Need to Tax Wealth More Effectively uhh, isn't wealth explicitly not taxed? The title makes it sound like there are taxes on wealth but the rich people
by gruez 5y ago
>Why We Need to Tax Wealth More Effectively
uhh, isn't wealth explicitly not taxed? The title makes it sound like there are taxes on wealth but the rich people just keep working around them.
- gnicholas 5y agoYou're right — the headline gives away that this is not a serious piece. Journalists often do not have input on headlines, but I would think that they would be able to push back on a headline that is actually misleading (or makes them look foolish, as it conflates income/wealth).
- jandrese 5y agoThere are a few ways wealth can be taxed, but usually only when it is changing hands. The so called "death tax" is an example, which is why it is such a hot button issue with billionaires that they propagandize it to the point that most Americans think it could affect them. A tax on wealth that is otherwise idle is novel. In some ways the system as it currently stands is backwards, as it rewards hoarding and punishes people only when they try to make their wealth do something.
- TiberiusC 5y agoCan’t you avoid estate taxes with a trust?
- gnicholas 5y agoTrusts do not avoid estate taxes. They can be used to engage in tax planning, but they are still subject to the same limits on tax-free transfer.
- TiberiusC 5y agoIn South Dakota, there are no estate taxes and there are trusts that avoid federal estate taxes
- gnicholas 5y agoThere are no estate or inheritance taxes in most states. Please elaborate on the trusts that avoid federal estate taxes! I used to be a corporate tax attorney, and worked in one of the leading international law firms for estate law, but have never heard of such a thing.
- TiberiusC 5y agoThey are called dynasty trusts and the IRS allows shelter for up to only $11.7m per individual. After a google search I see there are many more states that allow them these days.
- gnicholas 5y agoI think what you're referring to is the exemption from generation-skipping taxes, and subsequent assessments of estate taxation. IIRC, these instruments are still subject to the regular estate tax when they are first set up, which is why they would typically be funded with an amount that is exempt from the estate tax.
- gruez 5y ago>There are a few ways wealth can be taxed, but usually only when it is changing hands. So an income tax?
- nevinera 5y agoEh, it's a fuzzy topic, because wealth is essentially income at the top end. But yes, you're correct.
- gremlinsinc 5y agoInvestment interest accrual should be considered "income" at the end of the year. If I earned 20 and invested in stocks, I'm still taxed on the 20... if that 20 was earned from interest in stocks and re-invested, I'm not taxed on it.... That's where the change needs to happen.
- gruez 5y ago>if that 20 was earned from interest in stocks and re-invested, I'm not taxed on it.... By "interest" do you mean dividends? If so they're most certainly taxed.
- nevinera 5y agoHe's just being imprecise - he must really mean asset appreciation. (Reinvested dividends are still taxed, but lots of people aren't aware of that)
- nevinera 5y agoExactly - right now investments function as a tax-deferred account with no maximum, which allows billionaires to accumulate wealth without any taxation. They also strongly incentivize the wealthy to push for policy changes that reduce gains and estate taxes, because the payoff for even a short-lived reduction in gains taxes is massive when you have $500M in yet-to-be-taxed assets accumulated. If net-asset-gains in a year were treated as income, the actual tax rate could be cut by 80% and we'd still have increased tax revenue.
- gruez 5y ago>If net-asset-gains in a year were treated as income, the actual tax rate could be cut by 80% and we'd still have increased tax revenue. But wouldn't that only be the case because we're collecting the tax upfront rather than allowing people to defer it? Therefore the tax revenue might be higher in the short term because we're collecting everything upfront plus whatever was deferred in the previous years, but decades into the future the deferred taxes would dry up (because everyone's immediately realizing their gains), taking us back to square one?
- TiberiusC 5y agoNo matter who is in power, the wealthy always prosper, but at least one political party actively tries to reduce taxes for the rest of us.