3 ms·
Paid overtime will fix scheduling. Scheduling is bad because the cost falls on the employees, not the employer. If crunches resulted in time and a half, double
by Animats 5y ago
Paid overtime will fix scheduling. Scheduling is bad because the cost falls on the employees, not the employer. If crunches resulted in time and a half, double time, and triple time, scheduling would get fixed.
As I've pointed out before, film scheduling is an established discipline. Making a movie is much more complex than a software project. There are a lot of moving parts. Things get changed. There are people problems, weather problems, and transportation problems. Most importantly, if a film project goes into crunch mode, everybody starts getting paid overtime. This reduces the tendency to underestimate.
There are also third party estimates. Hollywood has something called "completion bonds". A completion bond is an insurance policy for the investors. Either they get a showable movie into theaters, or the completion bond company has to pay the investors. A completion bond costs about 5% of the cost of the film.
Completion bond companies do their own estimates. Estimation inputs are "script, budget, shooting schedule, (and) résumés of key crew." To survive, they need a net error near zero - they must overestimate and underestimate about equally. Consistent underestimation would put them out of business.
Since they do a lot of this, they have scripts and financial data from previous movies. They can look up "car chase, metropolitan area, 2 minutes screen time" for how much that cost the last 50 times someone did it. They also have director info, like "director X averages 2.5 takes per scene". All this info is collected across multiple film companies.
The completion bond company has the right to intervene if the project starts to go over budget. Worst case, they can fire the director and take over the production. This is rare, but it happens. "Malcolm X" by Spike Lee (1992) and "Bad Girls" are examples. "Malcolm X" was an epic movie, a bit too epic - it runs 3 hours and 22 minutes - and somebody had to say no to Spike Lee. "Bad Girls" (1994) was just a botched production, and the bond company put in their own director to try to salvage something. It still lost money, but did reach theaters.
That a completion bond company can fire the director puts teeth in this system.
- musicale 5y ago> Making a movie is much more complex than a software project. Software design and development is more like writing the books that the script was based on. Think Song of Ice and Fire, but 100,000 pages long and written simultaneously by a hundred authors.
- imbnwa 5y agoSoftware Dev is The Wheel of Time, got it
- astockwell 5y agoThis is the truth. Change doesn't happen until the decision-makers feel the pain of their decisions.