30 ms·
Assuming Robinhood's story was accurate that everyone was trading on margin (at least by default and thus a lot of traders) and that they were approaching some
by duxup 5y ago
Assuming Robinhood's story was accurate that everyone was trading on margin (at least by default and thus a lot of traders) and that they were approaching some serious questions about if they had enough cash on had to cover the trades / possible losses ... I'm not sure what the right thing to do in that case would be.
Keep everyone trading and possibly run out of cash to cover everything? Or stop trading and possibly hose the folks trying to make trades?
- sushid 5y agoThey could have also said that they'll stop giving everyone secret margin trading accounts and tell users that any trade (due to market volatility) will take 2-3 days to close.
- gruez 5y agoThe secret margin accounts is a red herring. They need to put up deposit with the DTCC even for stocks that's "paid"[1] with settled funds, and they can't use customer funds for it. So if you bought 1 share worth $100 and the deposit requirement was 100%, then robinhood has to come up with $100 of their own cash (or borrow it from someone) to fulfill the trade. [1] quotes used because settlement actually happens 2 days after the trade is made.
- ZoomerCretin 5y agoOther brokers without liquidity issues enacted similar policies. But you’re right, the fault doesn’t lie with them. The blame should go toward the DTCC who increased their margin requirements on buyers for seemingly no reason other than to coerce everyone into stopping retail investors from squeezing the rich shorts.
- gruez 5y ago>DTCC who increased their margin requirements on buyers for seemingly no reason other than [...] ...except credit risk https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-01-29/reddit-traders-on-robinhood-are-on-both-sides-of-gamestop https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-01-29/reddit... >[T+2 settlement] means that the seller takes two days of credit risk to the buyer. I see a stock trading at $400 on Monday, I push the button to buy it, I buy it from you at $400. On Tuesday the stock drops to $20. On Wednesday you show up with the stock that I bought on Monday, and you ask me for my $400. I am no longer super jazzed to give it to you. I might find a reason not to pay you. The reason might be that I’m bankrupt, from buying all that stock for $400 on Monday.
- ZoomerCretin 5y agoThe future price of the stock has nothing to do with anything. If I want a $400 stock, and you agree to sell it to me for $400, it is a done deal, is it not? The order is filled, regardless of settlement time or future price changes.
- gruez 5y ago>The future price of the stock has nothing to do with anything The quote in my previous comment covers that, specifically: >I am no longer super jazzed to give it to you. I might find a reason not to pay you. The reason might be that I’m bankrupt, from buying all that stock for $400 on Monday.
- ZoomerCretin 5y agoYes, I read it. You can’t cancel an order in settlement because you’re “no longer super jazzed”, else every order where the stock price increased would be cancelled by the seller so they could sell again at the higher price. Do you have any evidence that orders can be cancelled in settlement?
- gruez 5y ago>Do you have any evidence that orders can be cancelled in settlement It's not that they'll show up and say "on second thought I don't want that stock anymore, please cancel my order". It's that they'll go bankrupt in the meantime. This was already mentioned in the original comment. >The reason might be that I’m bankrupt
- SilasX 5y agoThe broker doesn’t have some way to credibly lock up the money so the buyer can’t back out, regardless of jazzedness or bankruptcy status?
- 5y ago
- jw1224 5y ago> Assuming Robinhood's story was accurate There have been several Congressional Hearings since January’s drama, and something definitely doesn’t add up. Robinhood’s CEO stated, under oath, that they switched off buys of GME following discussions with the DTCC. In a later hearing, the head of the DTCC stated — again, under oath and on the record — that Robinhood’s decision was entirely their own, and they had never spoken with Robinhood about it. Someone is lying. I would urge anyone interested in this (ongoing) saga to read this excellent investigative journalism piece here: https://prospect.org/power/how-the-gamestop-hustle-worked/ https://prospect.org/power/how-the-gamestop-hustle-worked/
- nrmitchi 5y ago> Someone is lying. Or, both people are stating the story from their side, and there is context missing. Robinhood: "We switch off after discussions with the DTCC [about increased reserve requirements which we could not meet]" DTCC: "It was entirely their decision, we never spoke to them about [the explicit actions they would have to take. It's definitely a coincidence that most other brokers did the exact same thing]"
- duxup 5y agoI agree. I don't think the description necessarily means someone is lying.
- jw1224 5y agoIt’s clearly ambiguous. Retail investors were screwed over by someone, and there are thousands of people still following the situation, demanding answers. Take a read of that article I linked, it gives an excellent and impartial summary of many of the conflicts of interests affecting all parties involved. It also brings up numerous issues I never see discussed here, given most people are only aware of the “mainstream narrative” — there is much more evidence being uncovered than most people are aware of.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y ago> Retail investors were screwed over by someone That doesn't seem clear. Possible, but not for sure. Too much of this reads like hardcore conspiracy theorists, but maybe that's just biasing me against the legit bits.
- greenshackle2 5y agoThe issue is not just trading on margin, it's trading with unsettled funds, which you can do in a non-margin account, because it's a non issue 99.999% of the time. Because of T+2 settlement when you buy/sell stock the actual exchange of shares and money only happens 2 business days later. If you sell a stock and then buy a different stock the same day you're trading with money that technically is not in your account yet, even in a cash account. It's fine because you wrote promissory note to pay $X in 2 days, but you're also holding a promissory note saying you are owed >=$X in 2 days. (And promissory notes to receive/deliver the respective shares). And there's a central clearinghouse enforcing this. But part of the reason why it's low risk is that the clearinghouse requires brokers to put up large amounts of cash as collateral to ensure they can pay all their promissory notes even if they go bust. They are fairly conservative in their collateral requirements. So when all your customers are trading a highly volatile stock with a notoriously high rate of failure to deliver (this is a whole other discussion), the clearinghouse gets antsy and may ask you to put up ridiculously large amounts of cash as collateral.
- gruez 5y ago>Because of T+2 settlement when you buy/sell stock the actual exchange of shares and money only happens 2 business days later. If you sell a stock and then buy a different stock the same day you're trading with money that technically is not in your account yet, even in a cash account. It's to do with T+2 settlement, but not with unsettled funds (funds you got from selling a stock, but hasn't settled yet). Basically, even if the funds were settled (eg. it's been sitting in your account for years), your broker has to put up the deposit on the day of trade, but can't use your money to do it. So if you bought $100 worth of shares and the deposit requirement was 100%, then your broker has to come up with $100 of their own cash (or borrow it from someone) to fulfill the trade. https://finance.yahoo.com/video/heres-why-robinhood-restricting-users-173049721.html https://finance.yahoo.com/video/heres-why-robinhood-restrict... >but our clearing firm simply cannot afford the cost to settle those trades. We cannot use customer funds to front that cost due to regulation. So the brokerages or the clearing firms have to go into their own pockets to do it. And they simply can't afford the cost of that trade clearance.
- 5y ago