3 ms·
> However, legally, the most recent Oracle vs. Google case has already settled a major point: APIs don't violate copyright. And as Github co-pilot is API (A sel
by toyg 5y ago
> However, legally, the most recent Oracle vs. Google case has already settled a major point: APIs don't violate copyright. And as Github co-pilot is API (A self-modifying one, but an API nonetheless), Microsoft has a good defense.
That's... a mind-bendingly bad take. Google took an API definition and duplicated it; Copilot is taking general code and (allegedly) duplicating it. This was not done in order to enable any sort of interoperability or compatibility.
The "API defense" would apply if Copilot only produced API-related code, or (against CP) if someone reproduced the interfaces copilot exposes to consumers.
> Microsoft has a good defense.
MS has many good defenses (transformative work, github agreements, etc etc), but this is not one of them.