3 ms·
It is often claimed that the Germans didn't believe Enigma could be broken, but that's false, they simply didn't believe anybody would put the work in and it wa
by tialaramex 5y ago
It is often claimed that the Germans didn't believe Enigma could be broken, but that's false, they simply didn't believe anybody would put the work in and it was indeed a lot of work.
Trying to guess what your enemy is thinking is crucial yet very difficult work in a war like that. In "Most Secret War" R.V. Jones provides excerpts from some of the documents he wrote trying to do exactly this, based on what he believed his German equivalents would or ought to know e.g.
"A representative from Rechlin might point out that even if they could not go to decimeters, the use of frequency modulation with the present system might provide some immunity from jamming".
[ This is referring to the Germans' previously successful radio direction finding for bomber aircraft, which by this point the British are jamming. In the "fog of war" some German pilots believe the signal isn't jammed but "bent" sending them off course, in reality the British never developed the sophisticated calibration needed to actually do this, they just jammed the signals with powerful transmitters, but doubt set in anyway ]
- mhh__ 5y agoMost Secret War is a really really great book, lots of lessons for today's crisis decision makers. Since you have are familiar with the man, there is a great PhD thesis online somewhere analysing Jones's work - he is the only source on manner matters here and he did have an ego. I'll link it when I can find it again. He was passed up for the SciInt job at MI5 post-war for having the wrong background, apparently. Shame, might have put some more pressure on Philby and friends.
- xyzzy123 5y agoThis reminds me a bit of the invention of "chaff", which the British and Germans invented independently. Each side held back on using it because they didn't want to tip the other side off. It's curious to think what would have happened if one side or the other had discovered that their opponent knew about it too.
- mhh__ 5y agoThey did know.
- WalterBright 5y agoDoenitz had plenty of evidence that Enigma was broken (too many coincidences) but just refused to believe it.