6 ms·
The level of coordination required to fake 9/11 seems on a very different level than the level required to wiretap some central points on the internet. And that
by bawolff 5y ago
The level of coordination required to fake 9/11 seems on a very different level than the level required to wiretap some central points on the internet. And that's not even considering usa basically had a dept of wiretapping (the NSA) already set up or that the nsa's activities actually did leak.
- wp381640 5y agoNot to mention that the post-911 NSA surveillance program leaked to the NYTimes within a few years
- emoII 5y agoDoes it really require all that much coordination? Some top-level military exec(s) want the military to get more funding. They're in contact with Bin Laden. Bin Laden gets a bit of money to put a couple of arabs on a "work-trip" to the US. The military-execs offer a couple of pilots a "crazy increase to their life insurance". Check their schedules to coordinate the day of the attack. I know there's a lot of detail left out and a lot of assumptions made, but I'm not convinced that it has to be an extremely complex and coordinated plan.
- ddxxdd 5y agoMilitary funding of Bin Laden isn't that far-fetched, and it may have possibly been true in the past[0], but 9/11 truthers believe that the World Trade Center was taken down by missiles and controlled demolition, and that people who thought they saw a plane were confused. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_CIA_assistance_to_Osama_bin_Laden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allegations_of_CIA_assistance_...
- jcbrand 5y agoAFAIK most "truthers" don't subscribe to the missile theory when it comes to the towers (the Pentagon is a different story). I sometimes wonder whether the more out there conspiracy theories are simply used to discredit any concern or skepticism of the official narrative by lumping those concerned with the crazies.
- koolba 5y ago> I sometimes wonder whether the more out there conspiracy theories are simply used to discredit any concern or skepticism of the official narrative by lumping those concerned with the crazies. You can see this with every time that the COVID lab leak discussion gets equated with lab creation.
- meowface 5y agoAnd also creation for research/treatment development purposes vs. bioweapon purposes.
- adevx 5y agoThat is indeed a well known tactic. In the same way as critics of mass vaccinating a global population with an experimental vaccine are lumped together with anti-vaxxers who believe in a nanobot spiked mRNA vaccine by Bill Gates.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- atatatat 5y agoRight — why isn't it cool to distinguish, and rank, various adjacent conspiracy theory likelihoods anymore?
- Ieghaehia9 5y agoI tend to call that tactic "Joe Greening", from the guy in the original Deus Ex who mixed the (in-universe true) conspiracy theories with alien nonsense to discredit people who knew about the conspiracies. https://deusex.fandom.com/wiki/Joe_Greene https://deusex.fandom.com/wiki/Joe_Greene
- nerdponx 5y agoThis comes up in The X-Files, too.
- 5y ago
- truth_ 5y agoMilitary funding of terrorists is nothing new. Pakistan as a proxy state of the US created the Taliban in Afghanistan. US wanted religiously motivated fighters countering the USSR. Pakistan, armed with US weapon, and flush with US money, obliged. Taliban was actually created at the behest of the US. It is an open secret. The US, to counter Al-Assad, armed and funded Al-Noosra front. Much, if not most of the money and weapons went to the ISIS. In the case of Al-Noosra turned ISIS, the US has plausible deniability. It doesn't even have that much of it in case of the next generation of the Mujahids fighting the USSR being turned into the Taliban.
- atatatat 5y ago> 9/11 truthers believe that the World Trade Center was taken down by missiles and controlled demolition Speaking for an entire group, almost always going to fail.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoPffft...you got it wrong. "Zem planez have been remotely radioed in!"
- roenxi 5y agoThe sticking point would be the bombers themselves. Maybe they chicken out at the last minute and then expose the conspirators. The personal risk for the top level execs would be massive, maybe even up to and including a death penalty. The payoff is a budget with too many 0s gets more 0s. The plot isn't rational.
- AndrewBissell 5y ago> The sticking point would be the bombers themselves. Maybe they chicken out at the last minute and then expose the conspirators. Very trivial to deal with, if one of them starts to speak up you just send the FBI to conduct an "interview" during the course of which they can be assassinated, like they did with Ibragim Todashev.
- jcbrand 5y agoThe bombers are useful idiots. True believers that aren't aware that they're part of an inside job.
- tnzm 5y agoThat's what you need true believers for: cannon fodder. Unlikely for someone to chicken out if they're already heavily emotionally invested in the idea of achieving spontaneous unity with God by blowing themselves to bits.
- bawolff 5y agoI think the hard part is not doing it as a false flag op, but getting away with it after the fact. There was a lot of eyes on the aftermath of 9/11.
- shadowgovt 5y agoEspecially after the centralization of the American surveillance and enforcement infrastructure in The Patriot Act. The TLA organizations in the government are rival siblings. If the FBI caught wind of a conspiracy to orchestrate 9/11 perpetrated by the Department of Defense in the newly-authorized data sharing, they'd have run it to ground.
- mandmandam 5y agoHa. In fact, you could hardly be more wrong. https://nypost.com/2019/09/07/robert-mueller-helped-saudi-arabia-cover-up-its-role-in-9-11-attacks-suit/ https://nypost.com/2019/09/07/robert-mueller-helped-saudi-ar...
- shadowgovt 5y agoThis is not an example of the FBI caught in a conspiracy to orchestrate 9/11. If anything, this is an example of the FBI demonstrating, perhaps, insufficient willingness to pursue investigation into a politically allied nation... Not terribly surprising, because (for starters) the FBI's job is domestic investigation, not international. The CIA or NSA would be in charge of looking into Saudi connections to 9/11. After the Patriot Act, these responsibilities became intertwined, but in the timeframe the article's describing, the nature of that entwining was nascent, and it's not surprising the FBI would have continued to act like the traditional FBI.
- atatatat 5y ago> If anything, this is an example of the FBI demonstrating, perhaps, insufficient willingness to pursue investigation into a politically allied nation When you regularly use other nations to do your bidding, what the hell is the difference?
- AndrewBissell 5y agoNSA mass surveillance was not just a matter of "wiretap some central points on the internet" as a one-and-done operation. It required thousands of people to work on various infrastructure and operations and to maintain it on an indefinite ongoing basis. It actually would have required far more sophistication and coordination to keep quiet in perpetuity than doing 9/11. However, in point of fact, mass surveillance actually was kept quiet for years after it was spun up. Long after the evidence had leaked from multiple sources and become undeniable, you would still be called a crackpot if you said to someone on the street that all their electronic communications were being collected and stored indefinitely. Then, on a certain day in 2013, a former CIA employee dumped the NSA's files to the Western press, which obligingly flipped the narrative and dedicated weeks of extensive coverage to the government's shiny, new, and by then well entrenched panopticon. A surveillance system is ultimately most useful in its purpose only if the people know they're being watched, and the time had come for it to be unveiled. As always, a large amount of media coverage in mainstream press outlets was a good indicator of what it was that the state wanted people focused on. The massively lower level of attention drawn to the Vault 7 leaks (which were arguably even more crucial than Snowden's) is stark and instructive, as is the different fate of the whistleblower (obscurity in prison vs international celebrity status) and a good indication of what they don't want you thinking about. "Use Signal, use Tor."
- aarchi 5y agoThe Vault 7 page on Wikipedia lists a strange ordering for E2EE messengers. Telegram has the weakest security and has only opt-in E2EE for chats, yet is listed first. WhatsApp's Facebook ownership is obviously problematic, but irrelevant to the specific context. I'd reorder it as “Signal, WhatsApp, and Telegram”. > While the encryption of messengers that offer end-to-end encryption, such as Telegram, WhatsApp and Signal, wasn't reported to be cracked, ... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vault_7#Messaging_services https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vault_7#Messaging_services
- AndrewBissell 5y agoIt doesn't matter how secure the messengers are if every device they're running on is compromised.
- PicassoCTs 5y agoIs there a category of "reduced protective on the ground work to sloppy SIGINT surveillance willingly" to provoke a incident that would ensure future funding?
- atatatat 5y agoThis is one of the points of the article. Conflation of adjacent theories is an easy route to defeating them in court of public opinion. "fake 9/11" isn't even close....