4 ms·
This is a nice option to have of course. What kid hasn’t imagined mammoths or saber toothed tigers, or Tasmanian tigers and dodo birds (I’m putting dinosaurs a
by mc32 5y ago
This is a nice option to have of course.
What kid hasn’t imagined mammoths or saber toothed tigers, or Tasmanian tigers and dodo birds (I’m putting dinosaurs aside because they are tens of millions to hundreds of millions of years older)
But, while good for the imagination, where would we put them?
Their ecosystems don’t exist. If they did, people are encroaching on them...
So that leaves curiosities at the zoo (or special once extinct species travel destination).
Is that what we want?
And what about Neanderthals, do we bring them back? Being near human what are the ethics of that?
That leaves a safety valve for species going extinct. This would be a good use. But it can have the effect of people caring less (don’t worry, we can bring them back if we have to)
On the other hand... this and space travel....
- edgyquant 5y agoIn regards to Neanderthals, I think until such a time people can stop being bigoted towards each other we shouldn’t be reviving an actual different species (as close they are to us.)
- vimacs2 5y agoWe would likely have to generate such ecosystems for ourselves, probably in giant rotating space habitats which can be enclosed off from invasive species and poachers. So, to put it lightly, probably a few centuries off. We have never even made a truly self sufficient closed ecosystem on Earth, our knowledge of such complex systems is far too infantile.
- VRay 5y agoPeople make enclosed ecosystems in jars all the time for fun
- vimacs2 5y agoI should have clarified that I mean large self enclosed ecosystems, as in bigger than a jar. Something that can sustain multiple larger animals is to put it lightly - a major challenge. The mess that was Biosphere 2 should be a testemant to that.
- andai 5y agoI'm glad you mentioned Neanderthals. We have sequenced their genome and this will soon be possible. Whether there exists an ethical way to do it, I cannot say. (Probably not!) On another note, the amount of Neanderthal DNA in modern humans appears to have a beneficial effect, and I have been wondering about the potential benefits to humanity of increasing this percentage. For an interesting perspective on the Neanderthal mind: http://franklludwig.com/neanderthal.html http://franklludwig.com/neanderthal.html
- Bayart 5y agoThey're not near human, they're human.
- jollybean 5y agoThose ecosystems exist, they just had issues with reproduction, predators, possibly disease. We can control for them middle one a bit. Apparently there were some pretty exotic animals that Aboriginal cultures and Neandrathals wiped out, because of the low frequency of them. Didn't take too much effort on our part. In the same way that Wolves or Bisons can be re-introduced in some areas, probably some extinct animals can as well with a little bit of help.
- darick 5y agoMaybe it's just a theory but I found this video [0] interesting. Maybe some animals would not be so out of place if we brought them back. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RXAirenteRA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RXAirenteRA
- diggernet 5y agoThere are some interesting ideas in that, but it feels odd to be arguing for deforestation. Which doesn't mean it's wrong. Just contrary to the usual teachings.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoWhat if....a rich guy made an island just for these species, and turned it into a sort of amusement park for Jurassic-era species?