4 ms·
Necessary context is the military's unique needs and the vastly changed nature of warfare, which by themselves account for the value of portable reactors to the
by wolverine876 5y ago
Necessary context is the military's unique needs and the vastly changed nature of warfare, which by themselves account for the value of portable reactors to the military.
------------
In military history, a cliche is that 'amateurs talk tactics, experts talk logistics'. Logistics - boring old logistics - is arguably the most critical factor for winning wars. Napoleon was a master of logistics. Think of 100,000 people in the field (which isn't a lot): Multiply that by around 2 lbs of food per day: 200,000 pounds of food must be distributed daily. Think of parts for repairs, ammunition, medicine. Think of how much battery power they need, for example, just for night vision, handheld computers, etc etc - how much fuel is required, daily? Think then of their equipment, which consume enormous resources - how much fuel does one 70 ton tank need? A combat helicopter? With modern technology, electricity demand has exploded.
But delivering it isn't so easy. Unlike civilian uses, the location isn't chosen based on cost-effectiveness of supplies and access to infrastructure. And much more challenging, often there aren't centuries of infrastructure built, as with a city, and the infrastructure you use sometimes is destroyed.
------------
Also, the nature of warfare has changed dramatically recently. We're accustomed to war against low-tech guerilla fighters, not peers, and to WWII-style warfare (tanks, fighters, bombers, etc.), which will be as useful in the next peer war as mid-19th century warfare was in WWII - it was 75 years ago. The next war will be against a peer who uses sensors and precision munitions (e.g. guided missiles/drones), as the US began doing in the Gulf War. The combination enables you to hit targets accurately at great distances: If you can see the target (e.g. by flying a drone or satellite over it) within range of the missile (up to thousands of miles), you can fly a missile there. It greatly reduces the protection of distance - being far away from the 'front' isn't much protection - and it makes large objects, such as tank formations and bases, into a convenient collection of targets.
Among other tactics, the U.S. military is planning to have personnel operate in small, stealthy, highly mobile groups within range of the precision missiles; look up the new plans for the U.S. Marine Corps for example, which has already scrapped all its tanks. The huge generator and supply depots at the major base will be gone. Supplying a large base under precision munitions would be tough - how does the convoy or ship slip through? Supplying lots of dispersed, hidden, small, highly mobile units seems very difficult.
------------
Reducing those supply needs is critical, and if energy - one of the biggest requirements for modern logistics - could be removed from them because the personnel brought a nuclear reactor, then it could greatly reduce costs, reduce death, and increase effectiveness (because they have enough energy to operate).
I'm not saying it's worth the risks of having small nuclear reactors spread around a combat zone, but the benefits should be calculated in.
- not2b 5y agoAnd what happens when you're fighting an ISIS-like group, and they overrun your remote base and capture your mini-reactor? You've just given them a dirty bomb. Doesn't matter if the reactor is perfectly safe under normal conditions. They can take it apart and use the spent fuel for whatever they want.
- mr_toad 5y ago> up to thousands of miles Only for long range cruise missiles that can cost $2 million each. You won’t be firing one at every technical you see on Satellite.