3 ms·
At this point, how long before we'll be able to vote using the internet? Figure have people enter their social security number, date of birth, and the 20 digit
by vaksel 18y ago
At this point, how long before we'll be able to vote using the internet? Figure have people enter their social security number, date of birth, and the 20 digit randomly generated password that gets mailed a month before the election.
- simonw 18y agoConsidering upwards of 10% of all end-user machines connected to the internet are part of a botnet, probably never.
- andreyf 18y ago20 digit randomly generated password that gets mailed a month before the election Shouldn't this help with that? Also, internet-based voting doesn't have to mean you're using your own machines, just that you're using the internet to tally the vote. This could mean we have 100x the voting locations that we have now - one at every post office, public library, starbucks, what have you.
- juanpablo 18y agoAnd then somebody could extort you to vote in certain way and remain at your side to make sure you comply... or steal your mail and vote for you.
- vaksel 18y agoif someone wants to fix the election its really not that hard under the current system either. Dead people and pets vote all the time. Same with absentee ballots. And if its 1 address, 1 SSN, 1 password at least the person will need a little bit more info to fix it. If they steal your mail they'll still need to know your date of birth and the social security #. And sure thats possible for 1-2 people, but do you realize how hard it would be to do it on the massive scale? I mean lets face it, voting is a pain in the ass, you usually end up voting when its rush hour, and you have to wait a long time to cast your vote. Something like 40% of the eligible voters even bother to vote. Shouldn't it be a priority to make voting easier?
- mynameishere 18y agoDead people and pets vote all the time Yeah, zombie granny and fluffy's backing of John Kerry basically cancelled out our household vote.
- jmatt 18y agoAnd then somebody could extort you to vote in certain way and remain at your side to make sure you comply... or steal your mail and vote for you. How is this any different from voting using an absentee ballot? Those can be stolen, bought, etc. And I would imagine are less secure than your average secure website. The difference comes when an exploit is found. The worst case for internet voting is very very bad and could scale. The worst case with abseentee ballots - a mailman or election official steals some. And then somebody could extort you to vote in certain way and remain at your side to make sure you comply... Extortion and pressure can and is applied at voting locations all over today. My voting location is literally across the street from the Democratic local offices. It makes me very uncomfortable. They always have pollsters doing exit polls and the people in line are almost all Democrats. They are loud, argumentative... It's an all around bad experience. I think voting online would be great assuming someone solves the security problem (OTP through mail, etc, etc). And for the record I'm currently libertarian. I disagree with this sort of thing happening in neighborhood churches just as much as the VA across the from democratic headquarters. Though personally I've had no problems at churches. Maybe a bit uncomfortable but people were not speaking out and attacking people taking a non-democrat ballot (primaries).
- Fuca 18y agoHopefully never. If there is a powerful force that can infiltrate the counting process we need to have it open to the public.
- vaksel 18y agois Diebold open to the public? Hell in today's society I wouldn't even trust a human, because no matter who the person is, if they volunteered to run elections in their district, they are a political person. And right now the political climate is very charged "NEOCON WARMONGER!" "LIBERAL DIMOCRAT!". And given the opportunity they can easily make votes disappear, or state different results, which get confirmed by another political person. I mean I could understand the point, if the current system was infallible. But its not, so why not make the whole process easier on your average voter? More importantly, ME! I'm not going to go vote, because I don't feel like standing for an hour in line, just to cast a ballot in a state where the result is already pre-determined because of demographics. I mean if you think about it, your vote only matters if you live in the 4-5 swing states, all others will go Democrat/Republican no matter what you do.
- anthonyrubin 18y agoThe presidential election isn't the only election occurring in November.
- gills 18y agoI think that you should take your position to it's logical conclusion. You may find a contradiction.
- trominos 18y agoSo open it to the public. After the election, publicly associate each password to a vote; also make people register for passwords and keep track of the number of people who register. Then after the election ask people to check that their password is associated with the vote that they made. Even if only a fraction of voters do so, it would be hard for any potential vote rigger to tamper significantly with the process. And on further thought, it would be better to use public-key cryptography than plain passwords -- get people to encrypt their vote with their private key -- because then the public keys could be released before the election and it could be verified that there are the same number of keys and registered voters. This would be dramatically more secure than the current system.